4 ms·
I can guarantee that for the $1Bn Sun's shareholder's paid him for it - 14% of the total price Oracle is paying for all of Sun - Monty could buy MySQL back from
by gaius 17y ago
I can guarantee that for the $1Bn Sun's shareholder's paid him for it - 14% of the total price Oracle is paying for all of Sun - Monty could buy MySQL back from Oracle and do with it as he pleased. So why doesn't he?
- staunch 17y agoYou have no way of knowing that. Ellison could view even $2 billion as a small price to pay for owning MySQL. MySQL has been a thorn in his side for years, and now he owns it.
- rbanffy 17y agoGreat. Ellison owns a piece of software anybody can fork and use as GPL!
- nailer 17y agoHe owns the brand, and controls the direction of the product bearing that brand.
- gaius 17y agoWhich means nothing really. If Monty announces that MarisDB is "the real MySQL" everyone who's ever heard of MySQL will go with him. Everyone else probably doesn't even know what database is under their company's data. All Sun got for their $1Bn was the domain name mysql.com...
- seldo 17y agoI really don't think that's true. The "average" MySQL user has never heard of Monty -- I used MySQL for more than a decade before I heard the name of its inventor. MySQL's battle for the last decade has mostly been getting enough brand recognition that corporate environments consider it a serious, practical alternative. The brand IS the value of MySQL: it is a promise that the technology has been worked on by serious people, and will continue to be patched and improved for the forseeable future (however realistic that promise turns out to be). Starting again with a new brand is possible, but by definition it would be a new company which would have to prove its chops and its longevity all over again. Losing the MySQL brand would be a serious setback to MySQL adoption in corporate environments, and thereby a setback to the amount of money that gets invested in improving it. It is in the interests of all users of MySQL that the brand remain trusted.
- gaius 17y agoit is a promise that the technology has been worked on by serious people All those people have quit Sun and work for Monty now...
- jacquesm 17y agoMonty did not 'invent' mysql, it is a partial implementation of a standard. Losing the mysql brand would mean less than nothing, in the corporate world a brand has value in the open source world the name changes and everybody moves on. See joomla vs mambo and a ton of other examples. The only person that really seems to have a problem with this is Monty himself since he can't let go of his baby even after selling it down the river. Which plenty of people spoke up about when he sold it to SUN in the first place.
- rbanffy 17y ago"All Sun got for their $1Bn was the domain name mysql.com..." Which kind of bothers me because I really like Sun hardware. Every blunder Sun makes pushed SPARC closer to extinction. I hope Oracle keeps making the Type 7 keyboards with Control where God wanted it to be. That's not too much to ask...
- JulianMorrison 17y agoHe owns the ability to say "no" to anyone who wants a closed source license.
- rbanffy 17y agoYes, but those folks will quickly jump ship to other RDBMS. I suspect most will simply go with SQLite. I don't know of anything that embeds a relational database that has the requirements of a MySQL.
- blasdel 17y agoSurely Adobe Acrobat Professional absolutely depends on the power provided to it by the mysqld process it launches!
- JulianMorrison 17y agoDo you think he'd hate them jumping ship to SQLite? Supposing he actually is being Machiavellian, he wants MySQL not to be so strong a competitor for the middle and high end of commercial installations. He can afford to concede the very low end - Oracle doesn't play there, except perhaps with BDB (a minor sideline).
- ShabbyDoo 17y agoHow much does Oracle stand to lose if MySQL doesn't die a slow death? Probably much more than a billion.
- gaius 17y agoI don't really understand how that's the case. In 15 years as a professional DBA working with both Oracle and MySQL I have never found myself in the position of thinking, hmm, Oracle or MySQL for this project? It just doesn't really happen (no matter how much Monty would like to believe it does). I recently decided between MySQL and SQLite on a smaller project (SQLite won that one). I can see myself deciding between Oracle and Postgres one day (never happened in practice).
- ShabbyDoo 17y agoWhat if the Falcon engine comes to fruition?
- nailer 17y agoReally? Java (which is most of the value of Sun) and MySQL are the only Sun products in mainstream use. Solaris is in the same state as HPUX was 10 years ago, VirtualBox and Sun's Xen Product don't have significant market share. Why would Oracle want to sell MySQL back?
- mseebach 17y agoBecause they bought Sun for the hardware-business and Java. They sort-a already have a database, and if selling MySQL to Monty can save them some trouble with a bored EU regulator that gets its kicks from telling US business how to operate, I'm sure they'll be happy to. It'll have to be at market value, though, and it seems a bit like Monty wants a solution where he stays very rich.
- nailer 17y agoSo they didn't buy Sun to get the largest OSS database in the world? Sun's storage products are top notch but I doubt Oracle specifically wanted to move into the field. Selling replacement SPARCs to the banks that still have Solaris won't last long, Oracle know that.
- mseebach 17y agoSun has a very good range of hardware that goes far beyond SPARC, and Oracle is marketing it aggressively[1] They specifically cited Java and hardware in the acquisition announcement, and I have a really hard time seeing the strategic value of the MySQL asset. Oracle has much more to gain from a "come to us when you're ready to sit at the grown-ups table" position. 1: http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2009/09/29/oracle-scolded-by-industry-group-for-sun-ad/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2009/09/29/oracle-scolded-by-ind...
- nailer 17y agoFYI your citation is a link to an ad for SPARC.