3 ms·
Having a flag for planet Earth is an oxymoron. The very purpose of a flag, and nationalism in general, is to be a symbol of a nation, and the very concept of a
by teddyh 11y ago
Having a flag for planet Earth is an oxymoron. The very purpose of a flag, and nationalism in general, is to be a symbol of a nation, and the very concept of a nation can only exist in contrast to other nations. One side of the coin can only exist because there is another side. All of Earth, considered as a whole, has nothing to compare itself to. We call the sides of a coin “heads” and “tails”, but we don’t have a word for the “side” of a sphere, since it would be pointless.
(Incidentally, there are already a few symbols for the planet Earth:
Unicode 2637;TRIGRAM FOR EARTH¹ and Unicode 2641;EARTH²)
That said, there may be a need for a slightly related symbol: In the world today there is a common assumption of nationalism, so whenever some grand achievement is done, there is the assumption that it is done in the name of some country or other, and everything is done with a place reserved for a symbol for that country – commonly a flag or a heraldric shield. To contrast against this, we may need a symbol against nationalism.
① http://graphemica.com/%E2%98%B7 http://graphemica.com/%E2%98%B7
② http://graphemica.com/%E2%99%81 http://graphemica.com/%E2%99%81
- exodust 11y agoI'm not so sure. All sorts of things appear on flags that aren't to do with nationalism. You can put a smiley face on a flag if you wanted to, and hoist it above your outhouse. You can put a skull and cross bones on a flag and put it over your DJ mixing desk. There probably is intelligent life out there. If we meet them one day, and they have a flag representing their planet. "Hi Earthlings, you don't have a flag?"...awkward.
- anon8764 11y ago> All of Earth, considered as a whole, has nothing to compare itself to. Except other planets.
- teddyh 11y agoAs I said, Earth-the-planet already has perfectly good symbols. And, as dietrichepp already said, planting the Flag of the planet Earth on Mars just seems weird, so I don’t think the symbol was intended to symbolize Earth as a planet, but rather Earth as “where all the people are”.
- maus42 11y ago>To contrast against this, we may need a symbol against nationalism. The 'against-nationalism-ism' would just turn out like a nationalism. After all, it has a flag. Just look how the International turned out when they managed something resembling of the revolution they longed after in one corner of Earth.
- teddyh 11y agoWell, there’s always the “against centralized authority” symbol: Ⓐ