6 ms·
> 89 percent of cellphone owners said they had used their phones during the last social gathering they attended. Right there is where the author looses me. Th
by sandworm101 11y ago
> 89 percent of cellphone owners said they had used their phones during the last social gathering they attended.
Right there is where the author looses me. That online collaboration via the phone IS a social gathering unto itself. One is not fundamentally different than the other. Physical proximity is great, but it is a serious limitation. Not everyone has the time/money to physically meet their friends over coffee every twenty minutes. Not everyone lives in downtown Boston or NY.
> They say it’s a skill they mastered in middle school when they wanted to text in class without getting caught.
And why do kids text so much at school? Because they are bored to death by mind-numbing subjects and teaching that doesn't actually teach. Texting is the symptom, not the disease.
The ability to 'not get caught' while communicating with others is a valuable skill for nearly everyone these days. It should be encouraged.
- andrepd 11y ago>That online collaboration via the phone IS a social gathering unto itself. Still the fact is that it is inconsiderate, or plain rude, to be "somewhere else" when you are sitting with other people who all took the time to physically be with each other. If a few people get together and spend large amounts of their time on their phones, then why get together at all?
- joesmo 11y agoAnd doing it in a one-on-one conversation is not just rude, but puts you into the asshole category.
- tedks 11y agoI know of literally nobody my age who would ever think this. Why do you think you should have someone's complete and undivided attention just because you're within 5 feet and facing them? What arrogance. This is why your generation fucked up the planet.
- alienasa 11y ago> I know of literally nobody my age who would ever think this. I think that's precisely the point of the article. If you are in fact in the middle of a conversation with someone, then it is polite to pay attention. If you don't want to be in a conversation with them, then exit the conversation (i.e. tell them that you don't have time and walk away). Pretending to pay attention while doing nothing of the sort cheapens the interaction.
- shortstuffsushi 11y agoI'm not sure if this is meant to be /s, but I'm 24, and I find this behavior offensive as well. When I'm having a conversation with someone, yes, I would like to have their attention, and I'd surely give them mine.
- jotux 11y agoI'm in the millennial-age range and am quite irritated when someone sits on their phone when we're meeting in person. Electronic/social communication is, by its very nature, asynchronous. You can send a message and there's generally little pressure for an immediate response. Face to face conversations are synchronous and when you do something on your laptop/phone/tablet you break the flow of the conversation.
- hellofunk 11y agoI wish people more your age and younger shared your perspective.
- yareally 11y agoI think it just tends to be who you associate with. I don't really know anyone I hang out with that sits on their phone the entire time. Then again, I wouldn't put up with hanging out with them if they did either.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt depends. IMs are much less asynchronous. I think what's rude is breaking off one conversation into another one, regardless of media. For instance, it's incredibly annoying when someone comes up to me in person and demands attention when I'm in the middle of an important IM conversation with my SO. An no, my reply can't wait because I had a tempo of conversation, and the person on the other side of the phone can't see that someone interrupted me in person. Face to face conversations transmit out-of-band information through body language, and in the same way electronic conversations transmit out-of-band information through timing. Also reading timing is just as subtle skill as reading faces.
- walterbell 11y agoOne could also make a comparison with someone in a F2F conversation who is indiscreetly paying attention to an "other" F2F person or group.
- imh 11y agoNot only is it rude, but it's not a social gathering in the same way. That's how I read this quote from the article, >After five days without phones or tablets, these campers were able to read facial emotions and correctly identify the emotions of actors in videotaped scenes significantly better than a control group.
- sandworm101 11y agoStaying away from most anything makes you worse at that thing. Staying away from phones/tablets for a week might also make them less able to understand emogies, slang, and current humor (all vitally important for the youth of today). The OP places greater value on face-to-face conversation. I'm saying that the OP takes this too far, that electronic interactions should not be dismissed so readily.
- emn13 11y agoI think you overestimate human flexibility. We're hardwired for all kinds of face-to-face interaction. It's almost certain that emogies or no, no matter the amount of training, you're never going to gain the level of social insight and empathy while texting that you could have had face-to-face. You may have huge brain and trillions of times of the computing capacity of a simple calculator, but it's still going to beat you at arithmetic. Know your limitations and embrace your strengths. You're not some general purpose machine; what's the point in pretending otherwise?
- lmm 11y ago> If a few people get together and spend large amounts of their time on their phones, then why get together at all? Why do you care how other people enjoy themselves?
- andrepd 11y agoI don't. I just wonder what the purpose of getting people physically together is if they are going to be using their phones.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alienasa 11y agoI don't think the author is arguing that online collaboration via phones aren't social gatherings, just that there are appropriate venues for each. By all means, communicate with your friends over the internet using all the means availed to you by technology. On the other hand, when you're sitting at a coffeeshop with your friend right next to you, that isn't the time to be chatting with someone half way across the country.
- shas3 11y ago> And why do kids text so much at school? Because they are bored to death by mind-numbing subjects and teaching that doesn't actually teach. Texting is the symptom, not the disease. Actually there is plenty of evidence that texting and social media offer a similar kick as several other addictions like smoking, etc. it's akin to blaming teenage smoking on boring classes. Further, the teenage mind is susceptible to getting easily bored and to addiction.
- nicklaf 11y agoCan we please stop comparing any activity that our brain learns to enjoy to drug usage by saying that some neurotransmitter is involved? I'm sure one could just as easily say that getting the mail is like other addictions, because I chronically get excited at the thought of my latest online order arriving.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sidcypher 11y agoIt's only an ill-recepted drug usage if it starts remaking your behaviour as to increase consumption. Does the excitement and anticipation of getting mail significantly increase the frequency of your ordering? I assume not at all, but compulsive buying is a thing, and "some neurotransmitter" can totally make people addicted, so why can't I make a comparison when it is reasonable to do so?
- nicklaf 11y agoPoint taken; you are right to defend the drug comparison, so long as we're talking about compulsive behavior with negative effects. I do feel the analogy is overused though, mostly because the notion that chemical reactions in the brain are involved seems to have an unduly strong impression on people, whereas I imagine that these phenomena in the brain turn up in all sorts of human activity (see sandworm101's comment). There's also a negative connotation that exists with drug usage. I could be totally addicted to jogging, though ("runner's high"), with an almost totally net positive effect on my life.
- hsitz 11y ago"And why do kids text so much at school? Because they are bored to death by mind-numbing subjects and teaching that doesn't actually teach. Texting is the symptom, not the disease." You seem to have missed a main theme of the article, which was in first paragraph: "Now they use it when they want to be both with their friends and, as some put it, 'elsewhere.'"
- kamaal 11y ago>>Because they are bored to death by mind-numbing subjects and teaching that doesn't actually teach. I would say an illusion of financial security does that too. If your life depended on getting a decent education, petty indulgences like this wouldn't even occur.
- douche 11y agoThat would imply that education and school are in some way related. Perhaps they can be, but often as not, school has more in common with a minimum security prison where children are warehoused during working hours.
- jfoutz 11y agoeh, kids have been passing notes in class since they had access to paper. Personally, i've been following the maxim "Prefer a warm body over a cold screen." I turn off (most) notifications. Sure, sometimes i'll pull out my phone to look something up. I'll check from time to time if i'm coordinating with someone, but i try to let my interlocutor know what's going on.