3 ms·
One intrinsic drawback in the concept of overlay journals is however that is does not allow for double-blind reviews. Until this is widely implemented I think t
by sonium 11y ago
One intrinsic drawback in the concept of overlay journals is however that is does not allow for double-blind reviews.
Until this is widely implemented I think the publishing process won't be fair.
- freddref 11y agoI'd be fine with reviews being openly attributed to the author. Authors reviews could be counted as contributions. Also, it might improve review quality.
- greglindahl 11y ago100% of the time that I've done "double blind" reviews, it was easy to guess what research group the authors were from. And I've seen reviews where it was easy to guess who the reviewer is: "Paper fails to cite the seminal work of..."