2 ms·
> Astronomers use the pulsar timing to detect the slowing of orbital motion due to gravitational wave emission. Correct, at least that's the theory But that's
by raverbashing 11y ago
> Astronomers use the pulsar timing to detect the slowing of orbital motion due to gravitational wave emission.
Correct, at least that's the theory
But that's not evidence of gravitational waves per se, rather an evidence that a spinning binary system will have a velocity decay (and gravitational waves fit the description of what might be happening)
So maybe there's an issue with how we measure it, how it actually affects matter or "it's complicated"/"it doesn't exist"
- versteegen 11y agoBut the rate of orbital decay of pulsars in binary systems is very precisely matched by general relativity, which is going to be very hard to explain with a different cause. Given that GR has been verified so thoroughly, while on the other hand models of the gravitational background depend on so many assumptions and simulations and approximately measured empirical relationships about supermassive black hole (SMBH) sizes, occurrences, time for SMBH mergers, etc, as detailed in the article, clearly this is incredibly weak evidence that gravitational waves don't exist. But something is wrong somewhere.