3 ms·
> So revolutionary is this new genome editing technique that rival groups, who each claim to have been first to the tech, are bitterly fighting over the CRISPR/
by mtgx 11y ago
> So revolutionary is this new genome editing technique that rival groups, who each claim to have been first to the tech, are bitterly fighting over the CRISPR/Cas9 patent. This new gene-editing protein called Cpf1—and maybe even others yet to be discovered—means that one patent may not be so powerful after all.
Just goes to show the silliness of patents. Even the lightbulb was invented by multiple people at the same time. Yet only one got to have a 20 year monopoly over it. Why should that be the case when multiple people invent it at the same time? Just let them compete. Competition is always good.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoThe standard argument for patents is that patents require that the method be disclosed. Otherwise discoveries are kept as trade secrets rather than being published for anyone to use after the patent expires.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBut is that even needed anymore with so many people able to come up with the same discovery simultaneously? Patents are no longer providing for pushing forward the sciences and humanity, merely rent seeking.
- karmelapple 11y agoThis patent allows the process to be used without cost for research purposes, but requires money be paid to the patent holder when used in a product for profit. Is this a good way for a research organization - typically a university- to have a sort of "profit sharing" arrangement with private industry, while still allowing scientific progress to march forward? For-profit companies would not donate a fraction of their proceeds back to the researchers that came up with the enabling discovery. Isn't this just a way to levy a tax on those profiting from standing on the shoulders of giants, which can then be used to find more scientific discoveries?
- mjevans 11y agoWhen was the last time that you, a practicing professional in an industry that has patents, actually used a filed patent's data to solve a problem (which wasn't perpetuated by the existence of said patent in the first place)?