3 ms·
> none of us has enough time and resources to research everything, nor it would be the most effective use of our time. That's why, in general, humans invented p
by pdonis 11y ago
> none of us has enough time and resources to research everything, nor it would be the most effective use of our time. That's why, in general, humans invented professional specialization.
So basically, you view charities as professional specialists in helping people. My answer to that is, if they really were professional, they would not be giving away things that could be traded for at a mutual profit. Instead, they would be using their professional expertise and the concentrated wealth given to them by donors to figure out how the people they want to help can create wealth. Then those people could just trade some of the wealth they create for other things they need.
> You must because neither our heads nor our tools have enough computing power to account for every single person's differences and idiosyncrasies.
No single human's head does. But the combination of all of our heads, plus our tools, working together, each of us dealing with a little piece of the problem, does. Your conclusion that "you have to simplify" assumes that we can't divide up the problem. But we can.
> or me, it is immoral to hurt an innocent stranger badly in some way, in order to save myself or someone close to me from some lesser hurt.
This is similar to Singer's argument that, if I would save a drowning child, even though it might ruin my clothes, I should also be willing to save someone in Africa, even if I have to give up some luxuries. This argument came up in a recent thread on effective altruism; rather than rehash my response here, I'll just link to it:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10233978 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10233978
> for me, insisting that we should care about only those we know is also a cop-out
I'm not suggesting that we should only care about those we know. I'm suggesting that the best way to care about people who need help in faraway countries is to ask ourselves why they need the help in the first place. We seem to think that all they need is some stuff given to them. In the short term, yes, that helps; people get better food, better homes, better clothes, better educations, etc.
But we've been doing this for decades now (if not longer), and yet the number of people who need all this help has not decreased. The deal was supposed to be that if we gave enough of these people enough resources, we would stop the cycle of poverty; in time, these people would stop needing help, because they would have become able to create their own wealth and trade it, instead of having to have wealth given to them. That hasn't happened. And that means that, by fixing the short term problem, by sending money, in the long term, we are not helping.