5 ms·
U.S.-China Deal to Ban Ivory Trade Is Good News for Elephants
- kelukelugames 11y agoI'm not optimistic. How can China enforce a ban? I can't imagine the government caring enough to act. Give it a year or two before we celebrate.
- adamnemecek 11y agoTheir crackdown on sales of shark fins was relatively successful, it went down by 70-80% IIRC.
- mahranch 11y ago> it went down by 70-80% IIRC. Not even close, demand dropped by 29% (source below). And the cause of the drop was the demand itself declining rather than anything China did. Their enforcement was minimal, the soup itself was just becoming less popular. It was sort of like a fad. Kind of like the sushi fad in the late 90s in California. If it was due to China's actions, you wouldn't have these sorts of stories still: "Why Shark Finning Bans Aren't Keeping Sharks Off The Plate (Yet)" (http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/03/03/390449252/why-shark-finning-bans-arent-keeping-sharks-off-the-plate-yet http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/03/03/390449252/why...)
- adamnemecek 11y agoWildAid reports 82% http://wildaid.org/sites/default/files/SharkReport_spread_final_08.07.14.pdf http://wildaid.org/sites/default/files/SharkReport_spread_fi... I don't have access to the paper referenced in the article, therefore I can't really comment. The article also uses a lot of words such as 'should', 'may', 'could' so I'll need something a bit stronger than that.
- mahranch 11y agoDid you read your link? The numbers "were self-reported by shark fin vendors in the Guangzhou". Hardly scientific and it's only from a single city in China. I'd trust NPR over that source. NPR claims that while shark fin soup sales dropped slightly, harvest & hunting of sharks is still going strong. Though, the real point here is that China isn't and won't do much about it. Oh, they'll put laws on the books and make a big show of it as they do with everything, but it's just talk for the most part. Enforcement of those laws is another matter entirely. For example, their pollution and environmental regulations rival that of the U.S. So why doesn't China mirror the U.S when it comes to its environment? Because they don't enforce those laws. And when they do, a small bribe to the inspection team is usually all it takes to get them to turn around and take the day off.
- adamnemecek 11y ago> Did you read your link? The numbers "were self-reported by shark fin vendors in the Guangzhou". Hardly scientific and it's only from a single city in China. Did you read yours? I prefer a source that clearly states where the data comes from. I don't have access to the paper the NPR article references and I imagine that you don't either so we don't really know where the 29% number comes from even. Are you arguing against the bans or are you saying that they won't work. If the first, your arguments are kind of unrelated. If the second, sure, they might not work. It's worth giving it a shot.
- klagermkii 11y agoGreat job guys, east and west meet to talk about an African issue without involving Africa at all. The US is all happy to try and push for their own beef exports from cattle raised in relatively poor conditions, but when you have a commercial animal product that is from Africa and could provide a much needed export, everyone suddenly discovers their morals.
- adamnemecek 11y ago> east and west meet to talk about an African issue without involving Africa at all. Well at the current rate of poaching, elephants would be extinct in the next 10-20 years. And considering the corruption levels in many of these countries, yes, it's the consumer markets that have to solve this. > when you have a commercial animal product that is from Africa and could provide a much needed export, It's not a 'commercial' product when the ivory comes from illegal sources. Would you be for legalization of cocaine to help the South American economy? > would provide a much needed export, On the large scale of things, it would hardly make a difference for the living standards.
- klagermkii 11y ago> Well at the current rate of poaching, elephants would be extinct in the next 10-20 years. And considering the corruption levels in many of these countries, yes, it's consumer markets that have to get involved. Or you could let African countries farm them and have loads of them, just like you have loads of pigs and sheep and cattle and all the other commercially farmed animals which somehow are ethically different. Instead you create a "War on Drugs" situation, which not only is hugely ineffective at solving the problem, it empowers the criminal organisations within the country that grows the product. Replace Mexican cartels with African poachers. Now not only are we unable to make money from the animals, we're losing money having to pay for rangers, and at the end of it lose the animals themselves to the inexorable attrition from the poachers (as in the White Rhino). Then everyone in the West has a fat tut-tut about what a shame it is for the animal to go extinct, while refusing to accept farming as a less ethically palatable but more effective means of preventing extinction, and we just move onto the next animal. > It's not a 'commercial' product when the ivory comes from illegal sources. It is a commercial product because there's a market for it and people are buying it. It may be illegal, but it's still being bought and sold. Not only that but in the past we (South Africa) have been able to release limited amounts of stockpiled ivory to be available for sale, but these kinds of agreements work to make that impossible. > On the large scale of things, it would hardly make a difference for the living standards. Africa needs every bit it can get to help development and be able to become an economic power with its own valuable and unique exports. Even if it just helps a few thousand people and their families be independent and contributing to Africa's growth, that matters, and dismissing it comes from a position of real privilege.
- rdl 11y agoI'm curious how the alternative strategy would play out: farming rhinos and elephants for their horns.
- desdiv 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobra_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobra_effect >The term cobra effect stems from an anecdote set at the time of British rule of colonial India. The British government was concerned about the number of venomous cobra snakes in Delhi. The government therefore offered a bounty for every dead cobra. Initially this was a successful strategy as large numbers of snakes were killed for the reward. Eventually, however, enterprising people began to breed cobras for the income. When the government became aware of this, the reward program was scrapped, causing the cobra breeders to set the now-worthless snakes free. As a result, the wild cobra population further increased. The apparent solution for the problem made the situation even worse.
- adamnemecek 11y agoHow would this scenario protect elephants in the wild? Or would the extinction of species depend on the demand for products made from these species?
- gizmo686 11y agoIt would increase supply of ivory, and therefore drive down the price, making it less profitable to hunt wild elephants.
- adamnemecek 11y agoThat's like an extreme simplification of the situation. a.) Less profitable does not mean non-profitable. Currently, the poachers are being paid couple hundreds of dollars for a pair of tusks which are worth like $350K on the black market. There is no way that legalization would drive price low enough for poaching to be non-profitable. b.) Price of ivory for poachers is $0. Price of ivory for ranchers is $0+. How do you solve this?
- bickfordb 11y agoWe could also reintroduce elephants to North America
- sea2summit 11y agoChina has little rule of law; I have zero confidence this will be enforceable, but it's better than nothing.
- PackageUpgrades 11y agoWe might want to change what we call them, if we want them treated as something other than "Ivory"
- Steko 11y agoWorth mentioning: when Xi visited Tanzania not too long ago his entourage smuggled a bunch of ivory out. So yeah I'm sure the orders to stop ivory trading from the guys whose houses are full of illegal ivory will be taken seriously. http://bigstory.ap.org/article/c0dca42fbd17481989ad8946fe9e0152/report-africa-ivory-smuggled-china-state-visit http://bigstory.ap.org/article/c0dca42fbd17481989ad8946fe9e0...
- Theodores 11y agoAlso worth mentioning is that China is now the new market for seal pelts and seal meat. In 2010 they decided to start that trade with Canada, a move that contrasts with the most of the rest of the world where bans have been put in place. I suppose a case can be made for battering two week old seals to death with a sharp blow to the head, not forgetting to slit the arteries in their flippers before skinning them as we wouldn't want to be over-run with seals, would we? However, I am amazed that a new market can be found for seal products in China. I can't imagine 'braised baby seal on toast' would sell that well if sold in Europe. I don't know if you would get that many 'likes' after 'Instagramming' such a dish, which seems to be the reason for eating deluxe food these days.
- laichzeit0 11y agoSo I guess they're following the example of banning rhino horn trade. How's that working out?
- dghughes 11y agoNo mention of getting ivory from Siberian bogs from Mammoths a grey area since it's not from a living animal but it's a terrible loss in an archaeological sense.