3 ms·
Echoing what jasode said, I don't think this blog comment makes this much less of a Tao accomplishment, even if the comment was absolutely crucial. Tons of sci
by jessriedel 11y ago
Echoing what jasode said, I don't think this blog comment makes this much less of a Tao accomplishment, even if the comment was absolutely crucial. Tons of scientific insights can traced back to off-hand conversations with colleagues; the fact that this happened on a blog rather than over coffee in person is not relevant to priority claims. When insights aren't traced in this way, it's usually because the person just hasn't kept an exhaustive record of all the useful conversations in his head (rather than because there were no such useful conversations).
In other words, if you think this degree of collaboration is enough to characterize the discovery as not individual, then there have been no individual discoveries ever. But that's not a very useful definition, because there are clearly some discoveries that are much more collaborative than others.