6 ms·
Prebake: Block EU Cookie Notices with Adblock
- vruiz 11y agoThis is great not just from a user's perspective, also the fact that it exists helps pointing out the stupidity of the law.
- cornewut 11y agoI think law is fine and there should be only a handful of sites in the Internet that would need such warnings. Problem is the abuse of technology to track users.
- dazc 11y agoAdsense have recently notified publishers that they need to implement a cookie law compliance solution. I don't know how aggressively they [google] will have to enforce this but the possibility of losing adsense revenue will be a hugely motivating factor. So the number of sites the need such warnings is about to increase massively.
- cornewut 11y agoOr how about Google making a form of Adsense that doesn't track users? I somehow have a feeling that large corporations intentionally are trying to make this law ridiculous. E.g. why blogspot pages would need such warnings? Please Google just stop tracking.
- dazc 11y agoIt could be useful to give publishers this option. It would also be interesting to see what difference it would make in terms of revenue?
- vruiz 11y agoEven assuming that law was necessary (debatable), the idiotic thing was asking millions of websites to do this, instead of automatically in a handful of browsers. Not to mention absurdities like the fact that you need cookies to remember that the user doesn't want cookies, or even worse: https://twitter.com/jgrahamc/status/633551359774691328 https://twitter.com/jgrahamc/status/633551359774691328
- cornewut 11y agoI don't think the law specifies to use cookies to disable cookies and it's a good thing - lawmakers shouldn't care about technological solutions.
- blub 11y agoPerhaps something is deeply wrong with the way companies approach the internet if millions of them have to display a notice that they are tracking their users.
- vruiz 11y agoNo, I can see that you are not familiar with the law, I don't blame you because nobody is, since it's incredibly vague about when applies and AFAIK nobody has yet been fined. There are hundreds of companies doing wrong things, no doubt. The "millions" are collateral damage.
- blub 11y agoI am basing my statements on http://ec.europa.eu/ipg/basics/legal/cookies/index_en.htm http://ec.europa.eu/ipg/basics/legal/cookies/index_en.htm (the chapter EU legislation on cookies). According to this guide, the following cokies are exempt from consent: user-input (forms, shopping carts), authentication (for the session), user-centric security, multimedia player, ui customization, social network for logged in members. Seems quite straightforward and fair.
- vruiz 11y ago
- RaleyField 11y ago> I think law is fine I acknowledge some benefits of this law, but I vehemently oppose it from the perspective of freedom of speech. I know it's an american innovation, but I think other countries should adopt the same principle that code (and algorithms/protocols) should be considered protected speech. I don't like this law because it interferes with http protocol by dictating how the protocol should be used. EU should not curtail the speech of W3C and of any users of their protocol. If you created a popular protocol then other entities shouldn't suddenly and arbitrarily start dictating how users of your protocol should now use it. EU should either create their own version of http or create their own client for http, which would be relatively cheap as they would only have to fork firefox or chromium and add sandboxing bound to domanins. Some infrastructure is already there with sandboxing in the form of incognito/private window, it only needs to be extended so that each domain is automatically in its own sandbox instead of just websites you open in incognito window.
- oliao 11y agoI think they hoped this law would encourage sites that people don't expect to have cookies to not set cookies until necessary. Like state sponsored news sites for example. I mean, really: why on earth does a site like that need to set cookies? To remember which videos I have watched? The real problem here is probably Google Analytics.
- sp332 11y agoThe law does not require sites to put up giant banners for every page load. As belorn points out, this was caused by the interpretation of nervous lawyers and hasn't ever been tested in court.
- roel_v 11y agoIt's depressing that we need something like this.
- TerryADavis 11y agoNIST Randomness Beacon Summary: NIST is implementing a prototype source of public randomness. The prototype (at https://beacon.nist.gov/home https://beacon.nist.gov/home) uses two independent commercially available sources of randomness, each with an independent hardware entropy source and SP 800-90-approved components. The Beacon is designed to provide unpredictability, autonomy, and consistency. Unpredictability means that users cannot algorithmically predict bits before they are made available by the source. Autonomy means that the source is resistant to attempts by outside parties to alter the distribution of the random bits. Consistency means that a set of users can access the source in such a way that they are confident that they all receive the same random string. Description: The Beacon will broadcast full-entropy bit-strings in blocks of 512 bits every 60 seconds. Each such value is time-stamped and signed, and includes the hash of the previous value to chain the sequence of values together. This prevents all, even the source, from retroactively changing an output packet without being detected. The beacon keeps all output packets and makes them available online. DRBG Beacon System Diagram Uses: Tables of random numbers have probably been used for multiple purposes at least since the Industrial Revolution. The first published table appears to be by the English statistician L.H.C. Tippett. In the digital age, algorithmic random number generators have largely replaced these tables. The NIST Randomness Beacon expands the use of randomness to multiple scenarios in which the latter methods cannot be used. The extra functionalities stem mainly from three features. First, the Beacon-generated numbers cannot be predicted before they are published. Second, the public, time-bound, and authenticated nature of the Beacon allows a user application to prove to anybody that it used truly random numbers not known before a certain point in time. Third, this proof can be presented offline and at any point in the future. For example, the proof could be mailed to a trusted third party, encrypted and signed by an application, only to be opened if needed and authorized. NIST encourages the community at large to research and publish novel ways in which this tool can be used. A few examples of applications are described below: Unpredictable Sampling New Secure Authentication Mechanisms Secure Multi-party Computation
- lucb1e 11y agoTried this before and it helps only so much. Many sites actually don't work before you accept cookies (they pose it as a requirement and tell you that cookies keep you logged in, even though the cookie law is only applicable to tracking cookies) so you need to see the banner before you can see the page. Examples: fok.nl and tweakers.net.
- Udo 11y agoThis whole thing is ridiculous. While adding these widgets to blocking filters seems like a workable short-term solution, the entire cookie notice scheme is unworkable in the long run. The problem is, this crap will stack up in the future, and none of it will ever get abolished. On some sites, I get a triple-stacked legalese warning banner, and I have to manually close all three of them. Since internet law will only get worse, maybe it's time for a "real" technical solution to this. For example, if we had a standardized HTML element attribute to mark these widgets, browser/adblock makers could enable people to opt out of displaying them. It might look something like this: <div legal-notice="cookies">...</div> <div legal-notice="DMCA">...</div> <div legal-notice="terms-of-service">...</div> And ideally, there would be a JavaScript API to query this as well, maybe piggy-backed on the Permissions API: navigator.permissions.query({ name : 'skip-notice', topic : 'cookies' })
- Kequc 11y agoThese laws are still evolving and changing. Different for every country. We don't have something international we can build standards upon at this point in time. It seems to me there would also be an active push against any such implementation because it would make current solutions for getting around this type of cruft more effective than it already is. Although if we were going to go this route I'd like to see it be a server-side rather than included in the markup. The browser could detect that you are visiting a new domain and request relevant information upon connection.
- mstade 11y ago> These laws are still evolving and changing. Different for every country. We don't have something international we can build standards upon at this point in time. Not every country. This is EU legislation after all; any website hosted in one of the 28 member countries has to abide.
- kawsper 11y agoThe cookie directive is implemented differently in each country, so if you are doing business in multiple countries[0], you are in for a bloody mess. [0] http://cookiepedia.co.uk/cookie-laws-across-europe http://cookiepedia.co.uk/cookie-laws-across-europe
- prodmerc 11y agoWell, this is just funny. Or sad, depending on how you look at it. Personally, I'm annoyed by the cookie messages, but the law is supposed to help people. Blocking (or auto-accepting) them is basically saying we don't give a shit about this law :-)
- Kequc 11y agoCookies are integral to the operation of every modern website. They offer security in the form of features like csrf protection or maintaining login state between visits. There is sufficient protection for cookies in the form of encryption and a laundry list of further details which have been added over the years. There are far larger security related concerns on the web. The cookie warnings are on par with if you had to agree with Javascript running on any page you visit in the EU. So, yes, I want to auto-accept. As a developer I feel like I'm not going to make special considerations that ensure you can use forms on my website without cookies enabled. And I'm not going to find another way to detect and re-instate your login state.
- prodmerc 11y agoYeah, from a technology point of view, they're necessary. The law is half baked and passed only to appease people who worry about their privacy. And it really doesn't do much...
- cornewut 11y agoActually the law cares only about tracking not cookies. And there are a lot of ways to track users even without cookies.
- blub 11y agoThis law aims to protect users from being tracked across multiple websites. There are exceptions in place and most websites would not need to display any message, unless they are in fact helping track their users. If they include services like Google analytics they should absolutely display the message.
- liam_ja 11y agoHi HN, I'm the creator of this filter list. If anyone can spare 5-10 minutes a week to help me and a couple of others maintain this list (testing and merging pull requests, closing issues, etc.), I'd be very appreciative! You can contact me here or send an email to cookies[at]prebake[dot]eu
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kwhitefoot 11y agoCould you explain what this would entail? You might get more interest if people knew in advance what they would be in for.
- cpeterso 11y agoIf an extension like Prebake (which I realize just a filter list) added a 'DNT: 0' HTTP header (Do Track instead of Do Not Track), then automatically dismissing cookie notices would be a "legitimate" new solution and not be "cheating" (as some might call it). If the user also runs a ad or tracker blocker, well, that's their business and a different problem. ;)
- skrause 11y agoThis stupid cookie notification law was actually the main reason why I had to enable cookies permanently. My browser used to delete all cookies at the end of the session (when I closed the browser) except for a few whitelisted domains. Then these notices popped up everywhere. So where do the sites store the information that you've already seen the notifications? In the cookies of course! So if you're actually serious about your privacy and delete cookies you will the the notices every time...
- belorn 11y agoThe reason that the EU cookie law broke down is that directly after the EU directive was issued, several lawyers from large companies changed their interpretation of an older 1995 directive that dictate how consent is given. The directive says that consent require "specific and informed indication", but lawyers from very large companies decided that the act of continuing using a website was the same thing as giving "specific and informed indication", thus users agreed to whatever policy or agreement that is linked in the banner. I visited a conference during that time which had a panel where those lawyers was discussing this and even brought up a question if a person really could agree to 20 pagers of policy document from the mere fact of just continuing using the website, and their collective answer was yes (through one agreed that 30 pages would be too much). To my knowledge no legal case has ever tested this, and thus we got this ridiculous cookie notice system where things has gone from bad to worse after the 2002 directive.
- facepalm 11y agoThank god, ehm, the lawyers: otherwise we would not just have annoying banners, every page would start with an blocking dialog. No thanks.
- belorn 11y agoYou assume that every page need to have tracking cookies or that a websites would choose to have a blocking dialog if that was required in order to store and accessing information on users’ equipment. Even if we do those assumptions, its not a good result for anyone and there need to be some peace rather than war between the industry and politics, and making the concept of consent meaningless is a very risky move going forward.
- facepalm 11y agoAfaik you need it if you use Google Adwords. Not sure if Adwords could be changed in a compliant way. I recently started out to implement the cookie header on my site, and discovered things are rather unclear. For example, couldn't Google somehow get global consent for all Google Ads? There also doesn't seem to be a way to ask for consent and only trigger Google Ads if consent is given. Maybe there are some things that Google could improve to alleviate the situation. But advertising probably also depends on at least a little bit of tracking. If they (the politicians) want to outlaw online advertising, maybe they should just say so directly?
- JelteF 11y agoThere already existed a plugin for this https://cookiesok.com/ https://cookiesok.com/, but it misses quite a lot. Hopefully this works better.
- T3RMINATED 11y agothe EU Cookie notice was a law that was retracted and no longer applies if you still have a cookie notice you have not read the updated Bill.
- andrewaylett 11y agoI've been using a different filter list[1] for more than a year, and it's really useful as I already use self-destructing-cookies[2] to exercise control over which cookies my browser will remember, meaning that pretty much all sites think I've never visited before and therefore try to annoy me with their cookie banner. [1]: https://github.com/r4vi/block-the-eu-cookie-shit-list https://github.com/r4vi/block-the-eu-cookie-shit-list [2]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/self-destructing-cookies/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/self-destruct...
- DavideNL 11y ago> meaning that pretty much all sites think I've never visited before True, but also not True (unfortunately), because the websites can identify you anyway by your fingerprint: https://panopticlick.eff.org https://panopticlick.eff.org
- foobuzz 11y agoThis law is so badly designed it is beautiful. It warns users who don't accept cookies that the website uses cookies, at every connexion. It doesn't warn users who accept them that they're used, putting aside the first connexion. It should be the other way around. The website should warn the user that a cookie is used when the website just accepted a cookie from the browser. The privacy concern happen at this very moment, when you phone back to the website, not when the website phones you information.
- DavideNL 11y agoIt seems uBlock (Safari 9) doesn't recognise this when i add it to the 3th party filters/custom URLs - when i click "parse" i don't get to see a new row with a checkbox. example: this works: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/r4vi/block-the-eu-cookie-shit-list/master/filterlist.txt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/r4vi/block-the-eu-cookie-s... this doesn't work: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/liamja/Prebake/master/obtrusive.txt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/liamja/Prebake/master/obtr...