8 ms·
The problem I see with the title concept--caring for strangers at the expense of family, or more generally caring for people you don't know, at the expense of p
by pdonis 11y ago
The problem I see with the title concept--caring for strangers at the expense of family, or more generally caring for people you don't know, at the expense of people you do know--is that in order to effectively help someone, you have to know them. But no one person can know everyone in the world. Human beings don't scale. The only effective way to get a lot of people helped is to have a lot of people willing to help, each of whom gets to know a few people well enough to understand what will help them, and then helps those few people.
But for some odd reason, we don't think of "charity" this way. We think that helping people you know, so that your help is as effective as possible, is somehow less "moral" than "helping" people you don't know at all, so that you don't know what will help them.
- cjbprime 11y ago> in order to effectively help someone, you have to know them Or maybe not -- what do you think of https://givedirectly.org/ https://givedirectly.org/?
- pdonis 11y agoI agree that, if you have already decided you're going to give to people you don't know, it's more effective to give them money than anything else, since that is the most flexible form of help. Whether it is as effective as helping people you do know is a different question.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> is that in order to effectively help someone, you have to know them It is not strictly true. Yes, helping someone effectively involves a person who knows the recipient of aid enough to understand their needs. But that doesn't have to be you. You don't have to go to Africa and distribute mosquito nets to save lives. You can work on making those nets, and that is helping. Or you can have a well-paying job and use surplus income to support people distributing those nets, people who know those they're helping. Also, a lot of low-hanging-fruits of world-fixing exist on social or global level, not on the level of individuals. I don't need to know of or care about any sick person in particular to help fight malaria effectively - in fact, getting emotional is often counterproductive. What matters are aggregate effects. Number of people who would die but are not going to because of the aid is what matters. Average quality of life improving is what matters. But I think that's orthogonal to the issue of family vs. strangers, and conflating the two doesn't help with anything. I agree that we shouldn't treat helping people we know as less moral just because we know them (and thus get to experience their gratitude). But I also don't think that those close to me are inherently more worth than those further. I may care about my "close circle", but thinking they are worth more than everyone else is just nonsense. This comes naturally when you start extending your concept of 'family and friends' to the entire world.
- pdonis 11y ago> You don't have to go to Africa and distribute mosquito nets to save lives. No, but if the criterion is effectiveness, you do have to know that distributing mosquito nets is the most effective thing you can do to help those people. How can you know that if you don't know them? What if it would be more effective to teach them how to make their own nets? Or to make something they can trade for mosquito nets at a profit? (In other words, to teach them how to create wealth, instead of just giving things to them.) To know whether or not that's the case, you have to know the people. > What matters are aggregate effects. I don't agree with this as a blanket statement. I agree that in certain cases, aggregate effects may be the best measure to use; but to say they're what matters in all cases is going way beyond our knowledge. Individual human beings don't average; every single one of us is a unique individual. Reducing 7 billion human beings to a bunch of aggregate numbers is ignoring so much information that the claim that those aggregate effects are "what matters" seems incredibly presumptuous to me. > I may care about my "close circle", but thinking they are worth more than everyone else is just nonsense. First, the reason we have an instinctual drive to help people close to us is not that they are worth more than everyone else; it's that we know much more about them, so we know much more about what they need. Second, "worth" is not an intrinsic property of a person. It's a property of relationships between people. My family is worth more to me than someone I don't know in Africa because I have a close relationship with them. But the family of that person in Africa is worth more to them than I am. Saying that every single person must be "worth" exactly as much as every other, once again, ignores so much information about the individual people and their relationships that it seems incredibly presumptuous to me. And just so it's clear where I'm coming from: this whole viewpoint of insisting that we have to apply exactly the same standards to everyone, seems to me to be a cop-out; it's a way of allowing oneself to feel good while avoiding the actual hard work of knowing individual people and their needs, so that you can actually help them. People want an easy solution; they want to be able to just send money and believe that that's enough, that they're helping in the most effective way they can. They don't want to face the fact that helping people doesn't scale; one person can't effectively help millions of other people. One person should be focused on helping a few people that they know well; for millions of people to be helped, there need to be millions of people willing to help and willing to do the work of each getting to know a few people well in order to help them.