3 ms·
Nope. By issuing a medallion, the city grants the right to participate with known rules of competition in a specific market and it also has the obligation to pr
by mschuster91 11y ago
Nope. By issuing a medallion, the city grants the right to participate with known rules of competition in a specific market and it also has the obligation to protect the licensee from unfair competition.
The cities have failed to comply with their duty and so, in my opinion, owe damages to the holders.
- lololomg 11y agoHow exactly did the city fail to comply with their duty? It was always legal to call a (non medalian) car to your location and be driven somewhere. The medalian merely gives you the right to pick up street hails, and that rule is still enforced. The city is doing exactly what it promised.
- smsm42 11y agoIt's not a right, it's a privilege. And the competition is in no way unfair, the only thing that makes it "unfair" is that they did not pay to the city for the privilege. There's nothing "fair" in being forced to pay exorbitant sums to the city in order to do business. I could get it if the price was commensurate with the service one gets from the city - after all, roads must be maintained, cops and street cleaners must be paid, street lights must be fixed, etc. - but 250K goes way beyond that and is clearly just made to extract money "because we can" and to limit the access to the market. If the city has an unfair practice of restricting business and charging for the privilege of doing something that should be a basic right available for everyone, and somebody relied on that unfair practice to extract rent, and it stopped working, I don't see how one has a claim for damages anymore than Mafia racketeer can claim for damages when a racket victim refuses to pay protection money, or one victim could claim damages because the other victim does not pay anymore and thus has "unfair advantage".