4 ms·
This is a very short sighted view. There is a real need for an alternative to IRC - and closed source products do not cut it when we are talking about communica
by scrollaway 11y ago
This is a very short sighted view. There is a real need for an alternative to IRC - and closed source products do not cut it when we are talking about communication.
What parent is talking about is a real problem. There's micro-ecosystems out there around specific closed source products, all of them centralized, none of them compatible... and in the mean time, the only real decentralized, open source group chat solution (IRC) has a lot of issues [1] which shouldn't exist in 2015.
[1] https://plus.google.com/u/0/+JeromeLeclanche/posts/icC6gDToBsQ https://plus.google.com/u/0/+JeromeLeclanche/posts/icC6gDToB...
- chc 11y agoAs noted in the OP, Zulip is not a closed-source product anymore. But I'm not sure that really helps so much with the immediate problem, since it's more the proliferation of protocols rather than the scarcity of source that causes issues.
- scrollaway 11y agoYes, that's the title of the thread, you can assume I read that far at least ;) I'll give you I wasn't very clear. I'm super excited Zulip is going open source. And it's both the proliferation of protocols and the closed-sourceness(?) of the products that is problematic. Open source has two coupled benefits: 1. If the product becomes popular, it's easy to integrate with it, extend it, modify it, etc rather than just write an alternative from the ground up. This prevents the proliferation of new protocols just for the sake of an alternative. Right now, it makes no sense for me to go and build a FOSS alternative to Zulip. It would've made sense a few weeks ago. FOSS web services encourage/promote self-hosting. This also counts for something. 2. When extending a foss product, writing a gateway is a lot easier. Gateways don't slow down proliferation as much, but they do keep protocols somewhat close to one another and make it easier for users to migrate from one another. For example: It's been several years now and there is still no reliable open source XMPP-to-Hangouts gateway. But a Zulip/IRC gateway? If one doesn't exist already, I bet you there'll be one within weeks.
- lwf 11y agoWe have both already :) https://github.com/zulip/zulip/blob/master/bots/jabber_mirror.py https://github.com/zulip/zulip/blob/master/bots/jabber_mirro... https://github.com/zulip/zulip/blob/master/bots/irc-mirror.py https://github.com/zulip/zulip/blob/master/bots/irc-mirror.p... In addition to Zephyr mirroring, which we've had since 2012.
- scrollaway 11y agoHurray \o/ Congrats on the release!
- lwf 11y agoThanks :) To dive a bit deeper, while XMPP/IRC exists, and it wouldn't be hard to make the Zulip server natively speak XMPP to clients, that in-and-of-itself wouldn't be quite useful. A message sent to stream "ops" with topic "prod deploy" might look like this†: <message from='coven@chat.shakespeare.lit/ops' id='162BEBB1-F6DB-4D9A-9BD8-CFDCC801A0B2' to='hecate@shakespeare.lit/broom' type='groupchat'> <subject>prod deploy</subject> <body>Thrice the brinded cat hath mew'd.</body> <delay xmlns='urn:xmpp:delay' from='coven@chat.shakespeare.lit' stamp='2002-10-13T23:58:37Z'/> <addresses xmlns='http://jabber.org/protocol/address'> <address type='ofrom' jid='crone1@shakespeare.lit/desktop'/> </addresses> </message> But there aren't any existing clients that have the UI to: 1. Show per-message subjects/topics in a meaningful way 2. Allow users to easily reply to a message preserving the subject So we'd need client changes to make it truly useful. †: Adapted from syntax specified in XEP-0045
- lips 11y agoBut one more protocol on the stack with mac/windows/iphone/android clients is, IMHO, an entirely different ball of wax than a libre project with only a single platform under its belt. In my situation, the existence of mobile clients is clinch for actually pitching it to any org I participate in.
- rdtsc 11y agoThe problem is not just the open vs closed source. Even if Google, Yahoo, Slack all open source their products. You'd still not be able to send messages from one to another unless they also federate at the protocol level. So you can be connected with a universal "messaging" client to any of the available servers then send messages to someone on Google, or Slack etc.
- coldtea 11y ago>This is a very short sighted view. There is a real need for an alternative to IRC There might be one -- but this is absolutely not what this and Slack are aiming to do. >and closed source products do not cut it when we are talking about communication. Not sure about that. As it seems, for 99% of the world who only uses "closed source products" for chat, they do cut it. (Interoperability is orthogonal of course).
- zyxley 11y ago> There might be one -- but this is absolutely not what this and Slack are aiming to do. That's kind of a weird statement to me, because every time I've sold a techie-type person on Slack it's been by describing it as "private IRC with persistent history and a bunch of other neat things".
- twic 11y agoprivate IRC. Hence global interoperability and federation is not what this and Slack are aiming to do.
- scrollaway 11y agoYou're missing the point. Just because it's not what they're aiming to do doesn't mean the tech isn't appropriate for it. You're commenting on their business model rather than the tech. For all you know, Slack could be planning to expand their business to hosting public chat rooms, then your comment wouldn't make any sense anymore.
- pyre 11y agoYou can already get a hacked up public chat via Slack. There's a package (which is all set to run on Heroku) that automates the process of sending an invite to the Slack organization so that anyone on the public web can do it. I noticed this when the Bootstrap 4.0a announcement had a link inviting you to join their Slack: > For those jamming on v4 with us, we also have a dedicated v4 Slack channel. Jump in to talk shop and work with your fellow Bootstrappers. If you haven’t yet, join our official Slack room![0]. [0] https://bootstrap-slack.herokuapp.com/ https://bootstrap-slack.herokuapp.com/