4 ms·
Your argument as presented seems to conflate the right to access information and the ability to access information. (Not that you're necessarily doing this, but
by mikeash 11y ago
Your argument as presented seems to conflate the right to access information and the ability to access information. (Not that you're necessarily doing this, but the way you've written it doesn't seem to distinguish.)
For example, under the law I have the right to go to the Moon. But I don't have the ability. Having the right doesn't compel anyone to create that ability for me.
Back to the issue at hand, I believe the government should have the right to access any information relevant to a criminal investigation, if they have a warrant for it. But I don't think they should be able to compel the ability. At best they should be able to compel that people don't interfere, but the actual ability to access the material is up to them. So while I don't think I fall into that category of person you describe as "believe that they should have an absolute power to exclude the government," I also think that given the current state of technology, that power does exist.
I'm not really worried about backdoors. They look to me to be so ridiculous that it won't even be possible to attempt to mandate them. Even if they are mandated, how will that be enforced? The genie is far out of the bottle on this.
- snowwrestler 11y agoYou're correct to make the distinction, but when it comes to law enforcement, both rights and abilities originate in the same place: legislation. The law gives police the right to enter your premises if they have a valid search warrant. But it also gives them the rams, guns, body armor, etc.--the ability to exercise that right. From a practical perspective, lawmakers try to address both rights and abilities when crafting legislation that enforces laws. I think it's really unlikely that politicians would say "here's the right, but the ability is your problem." No, they'll write a law that gets the effect they want, even if means granting powers that seem ridiculous to us. There is no shortage of things that have the force of law today despite seeming ridiculous to us. I am worried about backdoors. They are being seriously considered at the highest levels of government.
- msandford 11y agoWhat if his house is on the moon, and the government wants him to give them a free ride (to the tune of a few billion) to the moon to execute the search warrant? I would argue that he's compelled to turn off the giant laser cannon to allow the police to get there without being destroyed, but not to let them use his personal craft. That's the problem with encryption, it's totally unlike anything else that exists in the world. It's impossible (so far) to prove whether someone legitimately forgot the password, or if they're just saying that they forgot it in order to hide/destroy evidence. What other thing quite literally may or may not exist, depending on the state of a person's mind?
- snowwrestler 11y agoConsider that politicians could just outlaw building houses on the moon entirely, to avoid this problem. Just like they could mandate backdoors in encryption if they believe it is the only way to give police access that the politicians believe they should have. EDIT TO ADD: I believe this is a bad idea but I am concerned it could happen. Also in terms of a phone, it's easy to tell if it is encrypted, because modern phone operating systems encrypt by default. So the question is whether a person can be compelled to give their password. If the person wants to assert that they cannot provide the password because they forgot it, that is a defense that can be evaluated in a trial. Is the person lying, or did they really forget it? The court system exists to resolve questions like that. EDIT TO ADD: I'm just making the point that the possibility that someone might claim they forgot their password does not in any way prevent the passage of a law requiring people to provide their password. People try various tricks to get around all sorts of laws--that's why we have a court system.
- msandford 11y agoI don't see how the contents of a person's brain can be discovered by a court. That's a fact which (so far) can only be known by the defendant. Even if a week ago they showed someone that they knew the password, they still could have forgotten it in the last week. It'd be like trying to determine with 100% accuracy what a person's favorite color is. No matter how many witnesses you call and how many decades of documentation that it's blue you have, that doesn't make it blue. It just meant it was blue.
- snowwrestler 11y agoIntent is in the brain and criminal trials do try to discover it. Oscar Pistorius shot and killed his girlfriend. "I thought she was an intruder; I did not mean to hurt her," he said (paraphrase). The facts were not in doubt; the entire case hinged on whether the jury believed he was telling the truth. I agree that there is no way to recover a passcode from the brain (outside of science fiction). But it seems like a court could rule on whether claims of forgetfulness are real.