4 ms·
This concerns me a little bit, actually. I know there are folks here on HN who believe that they should have an absolute power to exclude the government at all
by snowwrestler 11y ago
This concerns me a little bit, actually.
I know there are folks here on HN who believe that they should have an absolute power to exclude the government at all times. I'm not one of them, though. Particularly in situations where law enforcement has obtained a lawful warrant, I think they should have a way to get that information. People do commit crimes, and the police do need to solve them.
One way to grant the police access is to somehow give them privileged access to the encryption. For me, this idea is dead on arrival. There is no way to grant privileged access to the police without dangerously weakening the encryption in general. I'm a believer that encryption, properly implemented without backdoors, creates a lot more good than bad.
So what does that leave? It leaves compelling the owner of the phone to unlock it. If the police get a warrant to search your house, you are legally required to unlock the door and let them in. It seems to me that a passcode on the phone serves exactly the same purpose.
So, my concern is that if compelling the phone owner to unlock is not an option, it will put a lot more pressure behind the idea of encryption backdoors, as the "only option" to give law enforcement the power they need to do their jobs.
- navait 11y agoGiven that key escrow failed eventually, what is different today that would make backdoors possible?
- snowwrestler 11y agoBackdoors are an absolute bad idea. My point is that when a bad idea appears to be the only alternative, there will be pressure (from people who do not understand the technology but do understand law enforcement) to do it even though it's bad.
- LinuxBender 11y agoThere is no need for a back door. Phones are not encrypted once the user accesses them. The carriers can push and pull any files to or from the phone over the air. Some of them do not require a warrant. I was always told to never ask for one.
- brewdad 11y agoYou aren't legally required to unlock your door and let the police in with a warrant. They will force their way in without your consent however, in some cases with out asking nicely first.
- snowwrestler 11y agoTo which law enforcement will say: "but there is no analogous way to force our way into strong encryption, so we need to create one." To reiterate: I think that would be bad. Backdoors are bad. Given the choice, I'd rather have warrants compelling people to unlock, than a law saying that encryption has to have a backdoor so law enforcement can force their way in.
- rev_bird 11y agoThis is a very interesting thread. I didn't think I'd ever feel differently about this issue, but you've really made me consider some other implications of locking police out of phones. Thanks for chiming in.
- phlo 11y agoOn the other hand, if you can be compelled to divulge the passphrase to any encrypted container, what happens if you forget it? What happens if you happen to have a block of random-looking data? It might be an encrypted container -- or it might be something entirely different. If I were to go through my old hard drives, USBsticks and whatnot, I'm reasonably sure I'd stumble on to random blocks of data and/or encrypted archives with passwords long since forgotten. If I could be punished for not producing matching passphrases, those could become a huge liability, very quickly.
- iamcurious 11y agoPlus, it would be an easy way to incriminate. Drop an encrypted usb in the belongings of the person, and use that as an excuse for putting them in jail. Hell, it would be a lot more convenient than the War On Drugs.
- johnthedebs 11y agoI'd argue that it's much more important to maintain strong privacy rights than it is to convict the minority of criminals that would be caught by indiscriminately searching their phones. Keep in mind, almost all this data lives elsewhere too. If it's important enough they can still get it.
- BonsaiDen 11y agoThe real problem here is the fact that there is missing oversight on these court orders, since it might be the case that the judge handing out the order does not have sufficient knowledge of the matter at hand and so there is a huge potential for misuse by the police or intelligence agencies. In the end it boils down to the simply dilemma of choosing between either catching all "criminals" or protecting the rights of the people. The latter way of course makes life a bit harder, since you'll never be able to prevent all crimes and people will potentially die, but people die all the time, since dying is a a basic risk of life. The former way is essentially a rabbit hole, because it allows you to rewrite the definition of a "criminal" to just about anything you'd like and once you get a court order the "criminal" being is pretty much done with their life. This of course was and is still used in dictatorships of all kinds of sizes and employed by numerous secret police agencies around the world. Once there is a way to criminalize any action and then instantly "get rid" of that person, people who are going to use these powers WILL pop up and take over power. Now of course in the short term no third party candidate is going to show up on the US politcal floor and take win a majority in the elections over night and then install a dictator system based on all the pre-existing powers by simply outlawing all other parties and anyone who objects to the new rulers claims. But 10 or 20 years from now things might be different and if we don't fight over abuse of the law and protect the general public we might end up in a pretty bad situation someday.
- wpietri 11y agoCourt orders are oversight. Police are by law limited on their own. To go further, they have to convince a judge. The oversight on the judge? Higher-level judges. If you are arrested after a warrant that is later found to be invalid, the evidence collected based on the warrant is thrown out. This can go all the way to the supreme court. As it did in Franks v Delaware: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franks_v._Delaware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franks_v._Delaware
- pjc50 11y agoDon't forget the NSL system of secret court orders...
- pjc50 11y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10271971 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10271971 It's not totally unreasonable. On the other hand, there's the 5th amendment, and you are not actually required to open the door when presented with a warrant, that's just a way of saving your door.
- LordKano 11y agoIf the only evidence that someone committed a crime is on their cell phone, the authorities haven't done a thorough investigation and they shouldn't be rewarded for laziness. Let's take it one step back from electronic devices. If a corrupt businessman kept encoded records in a notepad, the authorities could compel him to turn over that notebook but no warrant can compel him to explain its contents. That's what encryption is. They authorities can seize the device but they can not force you to explain how to interpret what's in it. Fortunately, high profile data breaches have put the thought in the public mind that weaknesses can be exploited. We can use that concern to keep people from demanding back-doors.
- mikeash 11y agoYour argument as presented seems to conflate the right to access information and the ability to access information. (Not that you're necessarily doing this, but the way you've written it doesn't seem to distinguish.) For example, under the law I have the right to go to the Moon. But I don't have the ability. Having the right doesn't compel anyone to create that ability for me. Back to the issue at hand, I believe the government should have the right to access any information relevant to a criminal investigation, if they have a warrant for it. But I don't think they should be able to compel the ability. At best they should be able to compel that people don't interfere, but the actual ability to access the material is up to them. So while I don't think I fall into that category of person you describe as "believe that they should have an absolute power to exclude the government," I also think that given the current state of technology, that power does exist. I'm not really worried about backdoors. They look to me to be so ridiculous that it won't even be possible to attempt to mandate them. Even if they are mandated, how will that be enforced? The genie is far out of the bottle on this.
- snowwrestler 11y agoYou're correct to make the distinction, but when it comes to law enforcement, both rights and abilities originate in the same place: legislation. The law gives police the right to enter your premises if they have a valid search warrant. But it also gives them the rams, guns, body armor, etc.--the ability to exercise that right. From a practical perspective, lawmakers try to address both rights and abilities when crafting legislation that enforces laws. I think it's really unlikely that politicians would say "here's the right, but the ability is your problem." No, they'll write a law that gets the effect they want, even if means granting powers that seem ridiculous to us. There is no shortage of things that have the force of law today despite seeming ridiculous to us. I am worried about backdoors. They are being seriously considered at the highest levels of government.
- msandford 11y agoWhat if his house is on the moon, and the government wants him to give them a free ride (to the tune of a few billion) to the moon to execute the search warrant? I would argue that he's compelled to turn off the giant laser cannon to allow the police to get there without being destroyed, but not to let them use his personal craft. That's the problem with encryption, it's totally unlike anything else that exists in the world. It's impossible (so far) to prove whether someone legitimately forgot the password, or if they're just saying that they forgot it in order to hide/destroy evidence. What other thing quite literally may or may not exist, depending on the state of a person's mind?
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> So what does that leave? It leaves compelling the owner of the phone to unlock it. You're constructing a false dichotomy. Backdooring all encryption and compelling the accused to provide a password are not the only alternatives. And they're both terrible. You seem to understand why backdoors are problematic. If we require the government to prove the original crime in order to convict for refusing to testify then there is no point in making refusal to testify a crime, because any time they could prosecute for it they could already prove the original crime and don't need the testimony. The only way it helps the government is if they are also allowed to convict people who refuse to testify when being prosecuted for crimes they did not commit. You might argue that an innocent person can be vindicated by telling the truth instead of refusing to testify, so innocent people don't need to refuse to testify. But that doesn't work when the government is playing "show me the man and I'll show you the crime." Everything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law and lying to the police is illegal. You have to be allowed to shut up or the government would be able to convict anyone they want just by compelling them to keep talking until the imperfect human in the fish bowl says something a court will accept as incriminating evidence. So you want to make an exception for passwords. But if passwords are different than other testimony it's because we should be more protective of them. They're the ultimate fishing expedition. There is no relationship between the password and the crime. If there is no evidence of the crime under investigation whatsoever (perhaps because you didn't do it), they still get to see everything on your phone. Then they can charge you with whatever completely unrelated crime their fishing expedition uncovered and use parallel construction to bypass any restrictions on what the original evidence was supposed to be used for. Moreover, it remains possible to investigate crimes even if you can't look at the contents of every suspect's device. You still have all the evidence supplied by the victim and witnesses and all the methods of traditional police work that existed before everyone started carrying around personal surveillance devices. Being able to force suspects to supply their passwords might help, but lots of things might help, and most of those things might help enough that it would at least slightly increase the percentage of guilty people convicted. That only tells you that some civil rights come at the cost of not convicting some guilty people. It doesn't imply that we should erase every one that does. Roper: So now you'd give the Devil benefit of law! More: Yes. What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil? Roper: I'd cut down every law in England to do that! More: Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned round on you — where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country's planted thick with laws from coast to coast — man's laws, not God's — and if you cut them down — and you're just the man to do it — d'you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake.
- Zigurd 11y agoIf a crime is so overwhelmingly in cyberspace that only the evidence on a computer would make the case, I'm very skeptical that that is the kind of crime that would impact me if it went unsolved.