4 ms·
The analogy I've often heard is that it's like a safe. Presented with the proper warrants, you can't refuse to open a safe on the basis of the 5th ammendment.
by ams6110 11y ago
The analogy I've often heard is that it's like a safe. Presented with the proper warrants, you can't refuse to open a safe on the basis of the 5th ammendment.
- tormeh 11y agoYeah, that would be the closest thing I can think of in the real world.
- derekp7 11y agoBut what if the safe had documents in it which was written in a language that only you know? Is there any circumstances where you could be compelled to translate them?
- mc32 11y agoSome bookkepers for crime organizations have from time to time used their own notation to keep the books. Typically, they have not been sophisticated enough to hide malfeasance, in addition, the shadiness of it is often enough evidence of wrongdoing, or at least leads to forensic accounting which reveals tax evasion.
- galaxyLogic 11y agoI find it interesting. It is crime to do crime is a tautology. But isn't "It is crime to try to hide the fact that you are doing crime" bit of the same? If you're doing crime OF COURSE you are trying to hide the fact that you are are doing crime. Does it make it more or less of a crime, since in practice every criminal is already doing that? Except terrorists. They want everybody to know they are doing it. Does that make them less criminal then?