6 ms·
A response to the graphic suggests that while "this was evidence of an insane and inefficient healthcare system", "if [they] really wanted a chart that capture
by cwan 17y ago
A response to the graphic suggests that while "this was evidence of an insane and inefficient healthcare system", "if [they] really wanted a chart that captures what’s wrong with America’s healthcare system, [they] should have gone to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ national health expenditures data website and downloaded the figures showing how rampant third-party payment has resulted in consumers directly paying for less than 12 percent of healthcare costs. And when people are purchasing something with (what is perceived to be) other people’s money, it’s understandable that they don’t pay much attention to cost." (http://biggovernment.com/2009/12/29/the-real-healthcare-chart-of-the-day/ http://biggovernment.com/2009/12/29/the-real-healthcare-char...)
I'm sympathetic to this argument given that the American healthcare system is considerably different than many healthcare systems globally in that private insurers acting on behalf of employers (not the users of healthcare) pick up a significant portion of the pie (even if, on a per capita basis, Medicare spending is more than most countries like Canada - though this fact alone begs the question of why the US government wouldn't first seek to fix Medicare).
As a Canadian, the one thing I don't quite understand is how many of my countrymen are so quick to condemn the American system despite all the obvious signs that the Canadian system is unsustainable and failing (http://network.nationalpost.com/np/blogs/fullcomment/archive/2009/08/18/national-post-editorial-board-canadian-healthcare-is-no-model.aspx http://network.nationalpost.com/np/blogs/fullcomment/archive...). Further, you read about Animal farm like anecdotes (to be fair, I've seen first hand some of this in Canada as well), and you wonder whether or not healthcare systems abroad can really be distinctly categorized between those that are "universal" and "non-universal" given how radically different implementation is - an example from Japan here: http://biglizards.net/blog/archives/2010/01/my_family_the_v.html http://biglizards.net/blog/archives/2010/01/my_family_the_v....
There are at least 2 other big problems with this graph if presumably it's being used to argue for changes in policy:
(1) The measurement of life expectancy "at birth". The US spends a considerable amount of money aggressively attempting to treat what would otherwise be considered stillborns.
(2) The lifestyles of Americans that may have nothing at all to do with healthcare implementation (http://www.usnews.com/health/family-health/articles/2008/04/22/obesitys-link-to-life-expectancy.html http://www.usnews.com/health/family-health/articles/2008/04/...) - ie this could very well mean that if the US miraculously grew an entirely public and universal healthcare system as modeled against XYZ country, US life expectancy might not necessarily get any cheaper or better - it is entirely possible that it would become more expensive and worse.
- SamAtt 17y agoThe problem with the Health Care debate is that it's become so polarized that advocates of Single Payer won't admit its failures in other countries while those opposed to Single Payer won't admit we have a problem. Graphs like this are designed to create a visceral response but rationally they mean very little if not accompanied by an item by item breakdown of why the numbers are what they are. For example, the Canadian system puts price limits on patented medicines while the U.S. system does not. That has nothing to do with being a Single Payer system but is definitely a factor that contributes to higher costs in the U.S.
- revorad 17y agoIndeed, politics is the mind killer. - http://lesswrong.com/lw/gw/politics_is_the_mindkiller/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/gw/politics_is_the_mindkiller/
- sailormoon 17y agoSpot on. People absorb some opinion from somewhere - it's almost a cultural, tribal thing. They adopt that opinion. And then confirm it endlessly via Google University's excellent and popular Confirmation Bias program, as demonstrated by the GP's links. All systems fail, even if it's only rarely. But as soon as they do people seize upon the failure as if it's some kind of conclusive proof of the gut feeling they had all along. They are seemingly completely incapable of thinking in terms of statistics and average, large-scale outcomes. This is, of course, not at all confined to the health care "debate". The situation is so bad that I wonder if some kind of rational risk assessment/statistical thinking course should be introduced in schooling.
- chrischen 17y agoAlso after a visit to a psychiatrist I found out they charge your insurance more, if you have it, than they would if you didn't. I'm not exactly sure what that was about, but if it was for sympathy, then it just shows that having a bureaucratic insurance company, private or government owned, would still have this problem of distancing the money from the patient. However I'm still a large proponent of not only life as a right, but healthcare too.