5 ms·
Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up taking to the sky
- rflrob 11y agoI would be curious whether electric planes significantly reduce the carbon footprint of flying. My intuition is that you wouldn't be dumping CO2 and H2O (both fairly potent greenhouse gases) directly into the upper atmosphere, so it would be a huge win, but I am neither a climate scientist nor an aerospace engineer, so maybe I'm missing something.
- ramidarigaz 11y agoLike electric cars, they have that nice abstraction layer where you don't _have_ to depend on fossil fuels. Just provide solar charging!
- anigbrowl 11y agoAnd where some of your footprint is fossil-based, industrial-scale scrubbers are a lot easier to install on the ground than loft into the air.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoOr generate your fuel at each airport (algae), convert to biodiesel, and then dump into your tanks as usual. Batteries may rule on the ground now, but we're a long way off from liquid fuel getting tossed aside in the sky.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoFor fuel generation, we're likely better off with using thorium power to turn air and water into gasoline.
- briholt 11y agoI was wrongly under the impression contrails reflected more sunlight, creating a net cooling. But it looks to be the opposite as you suggest. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contrail#Contrails_and_climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contrail#Contrails_and_climate
- Shadow6363 11y agoWater is a greenhouse gas?
- T-A 11y agoYep: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/monitoring-references/faq/greenhouse-gases.php https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/monitoring-references/faq/greenhou...
- credit_guy 11y agoNot only water (vapor) is a greenhouse gas, it's by far the most important. Per wikipedia, its contribution to the greenhouse effect is 36-72%, while the next contribution, of CO2, is 9-26%. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_gas https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_gas
- joekim29 11y agoSo basically, once we get technology that doesn't exist yet, we may get vehicles that take advantage of that technology.
- m4x 11y agoWell, sure, but you could have said the same thing about modern airliners when Louis Blériot flew across the channel for the first time in 1909. Electric aircraft are a technology that does exist, already. Two different aircraft have been built and flown over the channel already. Electric airliners will require significant additional tech development, but the fact that planes have already crossed the channel multiple times is a pretty good start.
- ams6110 11y agoLi ion batteries still have a LONG way to go in energy density compared to Jet A kerosene. Jet A, about 43 MJ/kg. Lithium ion, <1 MJ/kg.
- pasbesoin 11y agoPlus, you shed weight as you burn the former.
- tempestn 11y agoTrue, but you also shed a lot of weight by ditching the large jet engines, and you can distribute it more efficiently as well.
- prodmerc 11y agoYeah, battery technology really needs to improve. In fact, there needs to be some revolutionary discovery in order for electric planes (and a lot of other awesome things) to be feasible...
- blktiger 11y agoWell, that depends on the purpose of the airplane. We already have electric sailplanes which have basically just enough battery power to get the sailplane into the air, after that you don't need an engine. Plus battery storage has been improving at roughly 10% every year. Right now a flight of around 25 minutes is the point at which fuel makes more sense than batteries but as batter tech improves that number keeps going up. We are at the very early stages of electric flight and while it may never be a viable option for commercial cross country flight there is a good chance that it will take over a lot of the smaller, general aviation aircraft.
- waqf 11y agoHow about solar-powered planes? I would assume not having to carry an energy source (except for emergency use) is a huge efficiency win. And it's always sunny in the stratosphere (well, not at night).
- Animats 11y agoA related possibility is multi-rotor helicopters where the main power source is a jet engine, but the power distribution is electrical. One of the huge headaches of the Osprey is the mechanical linkage by which one engine can power both props. There are flexible shafts, U-joints gears, and a big clutch. This might provide a way to get to VTOL without insane mechanical complexity. NASA has built a big model tiltrotor craft with 10 props to test this.[1] There's also the Latitude VTOL drone.[2] This simply has electric quadrotors for VTOL, plus a gas engine, wings, and prop for sustained flight. So it has the range of a winged drone, without the need for a runway. [1] http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/188338-nasas-electric-vertical-takeoff-airplane-takes-first-flight-aims-to-eventually-replace-the-helicopter http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/188338-nasas-electric-ver... [2] https://latitudeengineering.com/products/hq/ https://latitudeengineering.com/products/hq/
- ak217 11y agoThe gearbox is an extremely heavy, failure prone, and complicated part of all helicopters. The gearbox alone typically weighs between 10 and 30% of the total dry weight of the helicopter. So replacing it with electrical drives does sound very attractive - and not just for the Osprey.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoElon Musk has said he would just put one big engine on a gimbal and just ditch the ailerons and everything. No clutch necessary.
- Animats 11y agoOne-engine VTOLs need an ejection seat. NASA built several "one big engine on a gimbal" lunar landing trainers for Apollo. Over the short life of those special-purpose craft, three pilots had to eject - two astronauts and a test pilot.
- Havoc 11y agoSuddenly Musk's cameo line in Iron Man 2 seems a touch prophetic despite being intended as ludicrous at the time.
- tajen 11y agoThe article raises all hopes, then finishes with the necessity of developing superconductivity.
- leoedin 11y agoWe have developed superconductivity. MRI scanners wouldn't work without it. The problem is that it needs to be cooled to very low temperatures, which requires complicated plumbing and expensive cryogenic gases. Not really something viable on an aircraft. Superconductors have been slowly improving in operating temperature though - perhaps the temperatures found at aircraft cruising altitude are within reach?
- gambiting 11y agoThe batteries have also another problem not mentioned in the article - you have to carry their weight for the entire duration of the flight, while with regular fuel you burn it up during the flight, making the aircraft lighter and more efficient. Not to mention, that many aircraft can't land with their tanks full - but electric aircraft will have to be able to land with the same weight they took off with.
- Sanddancer 11y agoI don't think that's an issue, especially with the projected use cases. The article says that they're aiming for battery storage of about an hour of flight time, which is plenty for takeoff, final approach, and other situations where you'd want a lot of power in a hurry. Most of the flight, unless it is a very short commuter-type flight where you can conceivably charge with shore power between flights, is going to be running much like a hybrid car, with the jet engine powering a generator working at the best point on its performance/economy curve. So it'll still use fuel, and still get lighter as the trip goes on. Also, those batteries mean you don't need a set of engines that need to handle the power needed at take off, so those can be lighter as well. So I imagine that a 1:1 replacement capacity-wise would probably have at worse the same empty weight, taking into consideration the lighter engines and the smaller fuel tank that would be needed.
- BetaCygni 11y agoNon-paywall link: https://www.google.nl/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CB4QFjAAahUKEwi_tYqN55HIAhVIbxQKHXGIA_w&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.economist.com%2Fnews%2Fscience-and-technology%2F21664944-using-electric-and-hybrid-forms-propulsion-very-different-looking-aircraft&usg=AFQjCNFpotPOlevrJ1nEQYgreE7hj1I_5A https://www.google.nl/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd...
- peteretep 11y agoI'm a paying customer, and I'm using your link because logging in on my computer will log me out on my iPhone, along with a security error. This, for content I've paid for. I hate the future.
- nkoren 11y agoThe real breakthrough in electric aviation will come when it is combined with beamed energy. Rather than storing power onboard the vehicle, you have ground-based stations which power the vehicles with tracking microwave tightbeams. That way, you only need enough onboard battery power to take off, land, and bypass one broken ground station -- maybe 15-20 minutes of total flight time. This would allow electric aircraft to be considerably lighter than hydrocarbon vehicles, even considering the current energy-density of batteries. Beamed-energy flight systems are being developed for space launch[1], but I don't know of anybody yet doing this for plain old aviation. It's a gap waiting to be filled. 1: http://escapedynamics.com/ http://escapedynamics.com/
- mrfusion 11y agoWhat about the beams killing birds? Maybe have three beams that don't converge until the plane?
- debacle 11y agoForget the birds, lets not microwave the atmosphere.
- nkoren 11y agoIf you think about it (or run the numbers), you'll realise that our present system of jet engines actually dumps far more heat into the atmosphere than this would.
- Sanddancer 11y agoWith the power you'd need for such a system, three beams would almost certainly mean three times the dead birds.
- nkoren 11y agoFirst, you can place the beaming stations on towers -- most birds stay within a few hundred feet of the ground (which is why skydivers don't have to worry about smacking into them). That'll rule out the majority of bird conflicts. Second, put a high-definition video camera aimed down the barrel of the beam, with enough field-of-view that you get a second of warning before a bird crosses the beam. With automated image recognition you should be able to switch off the beam within a few hundred milliseconds of detecting a bird. Switch it back on again when the bird leaves the beam path. Because the plane isn't being directly powered by the beam -- it's just topping up its onboard batteries -- the disruption should not be consequential.
- amalag 11y agoWhat about hydrogen fuel cells? I thought that is the high density energy approach electrical planes will take.
- mmariani 11y agoFor anyone who would like to watch a cool video of the MVP being built, here it is... https://youtu.be/qfBfZJBQH_I https://youtu.be/qfBfZJBQH_I