3 ms·
If you get a newspaper delivered to your door, you're free to pay someone to cut all the advertisements out of it before giving it to you. Yes, even if it's one
by derefr 11y ago
If you get a newspaper delivered to your door, you're free to pay someone to cut all the advertisements out of it before giving it to you. Yes, even if it's one of those free local 90%-ads-by-volume dealies. The manner in which you consume the content is yours to decide.
> willing to share it with you for free on a single condition which is that you keep the ads intact
It's very easy to detect ad-blocker usage (ad-blockers do nothing to mask their presence) and prevent the ad-blocking users from getting your content. No content provider does this. They instead choose to serve you the content anyway. There is no "condition" attached; they are choosing to hand you the newspaper, knowing you're holding the scissors.
If 1. content providers started refusing to serve content to ad-blocker users, and then 2. ad-blockers made themselves undetectable to skirt this, then yes, you could say the users were doing something "mean." Probably mean to about the same level as using Google to skirt the NYT paywall.
- nacs 11y ago> No content provider does this I've seen quite a few that detect Adblock and ask you to turn it off (the OK ones) and the ones that prevent content being viewed (the not-so-nice ones). In fact, the removal of these nag messages from Adblock-detectors has it's own list: https://easylist-downloads.adblockplus.org/antiadblockfilters.txt https://easylist-downloads.adblockplus.org/antiadblockfilter...