3 ms·
What I find kind of funny is how roles and identities are mixed up in texts like this to make everything appear wonderfully clear when it is not. He says: "In
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
What I find kind of funny is how roles and identities are mixed up in texts like this to make everything appear wonderfully clear when it is not.
He says: "In this case, too-big-to-fail financial institutions had perverse incentives: if they gambled and succeeded, they walked off with the profits; if they lost, the taxpayer would pay"
So we have the banks and the tax-payers he says. Are these disjoint sets? No, these are roles and there are individuals, lots of individuals, who are both owners of banks _and_ tax-payers. The more taxes someone pays the more likely they are owners of banks as well.
The perverse incentives were provided by these owners, demanding low risk and returns way above anything that could possibly be sustainable.
He goes on to say "It certainly did not serve homeowners who are losing their homes, workers who have lost their jobs, retirees who have seen their retirement funds vanish, or taxpayers who paid hundreds of billions of dollars to bail out the banks."
Homeowners are sadly losing their homes. Homes they wouldn't have been able to afford if it hadn't been for the reckless lending of banks. And those risky sup-prime loans, who bought them? Pension funds bought them (among others). Pension funds who demanded outsized profits for the benefit of exactly those people who now lost their retirement funds.
If the banks had walked away with all the profits or were saved when they made mistakes then people would not have lost their retirement funds, because the banks' profits _are_ their retirement funds.
Workers sadly lost their jobs. Jobs in the financial industry were lost. Construction workers lost their jobs building sup-prime homes. Many other people lost their jobs that used to be funded by people (themselves) borrowing like there's no tomorrow trusting in their homes gaining value and their retirement funds growing fat from fat bank profits.
Now, is this a zero-sum game? Have only people lost who had gained from the same system before? No, of course not, there were indeed people who did not benefit much and are now suffering hardship. And there are rich people who benefited and did not lose much.
But what Stiglitz does not say is that these people are few. Most people, particularly those who are tax-payers, are on both sides of the game in various different roles.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoActually, there are a huge number of people who lost: home owners (as distinct from mortgage-owners) and renters. Both these groups were forced to subsidize mortgage holders and banks on the way up and on the way down.