5 ms·

Is anybody aware of some effective examples of applying game mechanics to apps? (besides those mentioned in the video) The best example I know is stackoverflow

by macmac 17y ago

Is anybody aware of some effective examples of applying game mechanics to apps? (besides those mentioned in the video) The best example I know is stackoverflow.com, which uses votes, badges, reputation etc.

thomaspaine 17y ago
http://www.thesixtyone.com http://www.thesixtyone.com does a good job.
jfarmer 17y ago
To me "game mechanics" are just another way of saying "behavioral economics." Game mechanics are about exploiting irrational but predictable psychological levers in the human mind. To that end, there are lots of apps that use game mechanics, some more obvious than others: Foursquare/Gowalla are obvious. You get random rewards and points for doing various real-life activities like traveling and eating out. Opower. See, e.g., this article http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/greenspace/2009/10/california-embraces-psychology-of-influence-to-reduce-energy-use.html http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/greenspace/2009/10/californi... Mechanical Turk. Why would an American do work for $0.50/hour? It's not rational, and I think it's the game-like nature of mturk. Many websites use the quest/reward mechanic to guide users through the registration process and the first few key steps of the application, e.g., LinkedIn's "your profile is 75%" complete mechanic.
- macmac 17y ago
  I agree that behavioral economics greatly informs "game mechanics" but I don't think the levers it relies on are all irrational. My utility (pride, sense of accomplishment etc.) from answering questions on stackoverflow.com might far exceed the utility from the maximum monetary gain I could achieve from an alternative use of my time, thus making me spending time on answering stackoverflow.com questions perfectly rational.
zach 17y ago
Yahoo Answers and Yelp are the ones I would pick. I think the issue is more about providing a meta-experience as games do rather than the particulars of the game mechanics.
fara 17y ago
I believe HN is an effective example. Your karma are your points. Comments and votes give you feedback.And you also collect submissions.

by macmac 17y ago

thomaspaine 17y ago

http://www.thesixtyone.com http://www.thesixtyone.com does a good job.

jfarmer 17y ago

To me "game mechanics" are just another way of saying "behavioral economics." Game mechanics are about exploiting irrational but predictable psychological levers in the human mind. To that end, there are lots of apps that use game mechanics, some more obvious than others: Foursquare/Gowalla are obvious. You get random rewards and points for doing various real-life activities like traveling and eating out. Opower. See, e.g., this article http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/greenspace/2009/10/california-embraces-psychology-of-influence-to-reduce-energy-use.html http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/greenspace/2009/10/californi... Mechanical Turk. Why would an American do work for $0.50/hour? It's not rational, and I think it's the game-like nature of mturk. Many websites use the quest/reward mechanic to guide users through the registration process and the first few key steps of the application, e.g., LinkedIn's "your profile is 75%" complete mechanic.

macmac 17y ago
I agree that behavioral economics greatly informs "game mechanics" but I don't think the levers it relies on are all irrational. My utility (pride, sense of accomplishment etc.) from answering questions on stackoverflow.com might far exceed the utility from the maximum monetary gain I could achieve from an alternative use of my time, thus making me spending time on answering stackoverflow.com questions perfectly rational.

zach 17y ago

Yahoo Answers and Yelp are the ones I would pick. I think the issue is more about providing a meta-experience as games do rather than the particulars of the game mechanics.

fara 17y ago

I believe HN is an effective example. Your karma are your points. Comments and votes give you feedback.And you also collect submissions.