2 ms·
I don't use it to exclusively mean CLR-hosted, and to be frank, I think the meaning is pretty clear outside of MS contexts. I believe "GCed" focuses too much on
by barrkel 17y ago
I don't use it to exclusively mean CLR-hosted, and to be frank, I think the meaning is pretty clear outside of MS contexts. I believe "GCed" focuses too much on the memory allocation strategy; which while important for many of the practical advantages of managed languages, I think it ends up lopsided.
Finally, more people using a word in an alternative way is the path to controlling its meaning, rather than avoiding the word altogether, cf "queer" and the like.
- delackner 17y agoWhat meaning does "managed" have to you? I wasn't aware of a generic meaning. A virtual-machine-based language that happens to include garbage collection?
- barrkel 17y agoGenerally it means type-safe and memory-safe, at least by default; is not usually precompiled (in practice precompilation is avoided for linking flexibility); and has a runtime which is at least nominally independent of the programs that run on it, e.g. that would need separate installation if not packaged as part of a larger environment. The combination of type and memory safety usually requires a garbage collector, though it's not strictly necessary.