3 ms·
Thomas Paine made a great observation during the American Revolution. When the time came to form a government, some folks wanted a complicated system like the E
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Thomas Paine made a great observation during the American Revolution. When the time came to form a government, some folks wanted a complicated system like the Europeans had. Paine violently disagreed.
When you have a complex system, he said, there's nobody to blame any more. If a King masses troops, invades your houses, or taxes you onerously you know whom to blame. If a deomcratic legislature votes to fund a war, conscript your children, or change how people vote, you know whom to blame.
But if, as in this incident, an elected legislature sets up a complex, mostly autonomous mangle of agencies managing an also complex underlying system and something goes wrong? Nobody to blame any more. And that's not because of some political "trick" -- that's just the way complex political systems work.
As we create more and more complex political Big Design Up Front, Architecture Astronaut solutions to already complicated underlying systems, we tend more this condition more and more. That's what's different about now and 50 years ago, although David refused to connect the dots. People are no more or less "mature" now than they were in 1950, 1900, or 1850. This "blame the user" mentality of governance or company creation is only going to take you so far.
David is telling me nothing that I haven't known for 20 years, and nothing that western civilization hasn't known for 300. Welcome to 1750, Brooks.