4 ms·
I think what you think you'll do, what you swear you'll do, and what you actually do aren't necessarily always aligned. But that's also irrelevant. If they ar
by kbenson 11y ago
I think what you think you'll do, what you swear you'll do, and what you actually do aren't necessarily always aligned.
But that's also irrelevant. If they are paying to have pictures put in front of you for brand awareness, then that's what they are paying for,not ad-clicks. Assuming you can completely understand their business, strategies and intentions to the point that you can accurately judge what is best for them is not just naive, it's hubris.
- Nursie 11y agoThe fact that advertisers will use things like 'brand awareness' and other subtle ways to try to get into my brain against my wishes is, IMHO, an excellent reason for blocking.
- kbenson 11y agoThat's also a good argument for holing up in a cave somewhere and never coming out. The whole of human culture and communication is full of subtle cues and plays on how our mind works, and has been for millennia.
- Nursie 11y agoIn a way, when it comes to advertisements, I do that already. I don't watch broadcast tv, I don't read newspapers or magazines on paper, I listen to BBC radio if I listen to the radio, I have adblockers for the internet. Th world can be a quieter, calmer place when you stop letting people make sales pitches at you constantly.
- kbenson 11y agoThat's an easy decision to make when you stop letting them make the sales pitches, but still take what they offer in exchange for those sales pitches. If you stopped the advertising and didn't view the content they offered in exchange, it would be quieter, calmer and a lot more boring.
- Nursie 11y ago>> If you stopped the advertising and didn't view the content they offered in exchange, it would be quieter, calmer and a lot more boring. Not really, I already pay for my tv, music and radio directly (tv license, streaming services etc) so I don't have to be advertised at, and I'm seriously considering signing up for these various no-ad services for the web. It doesn't have to be more boring without advertising, in nearly all media now there are ways to enjoy great content without letting the sales pitch in. I hope we find good ways with the web too.
- kbenson 11y ago> It doesn't have to be more boring without advertising, in nearly all media now there are ways to enjoy great content without letting the sales pitch in. I hope we find good ways with the web too. My point was that it's more boring if you forego the content that has ads, and I think your use of an ad-blocker to access this content supports this position. I also hope we find good mechanisms to pay for content without advertising, but I also don't want advertising paid services to go away. It does allow a freedom of access that wasn't possible beforehand.
- Nursie 11y ago>> My point was that it's more boring if you forego the content that has ads, I dunno, I might get more done actually and have a more interesting life, but that's something of a philosophical point. >> I think your use of an ad-blocker to access this content supports this position. I think that if I didn't have one I would use the web much less, as I do find advertising that intrusive and awful now. >> I also don't want advertising paid services to go away I honestly don't care about them, I'd rather not have ads or the service and would be more than happy to see a model develop that blocks people like me from content if the advertising is that important to the site.
- kbenson 11y agoI agree it we would be better off overall with the ability to choose whether or not we wanted to see content if it requires ads, as that would make the choice clear to many people who I think it isn't clear for now. Ideally, I think we would be well served by a choice where we could choose to see an ad, or choose to pony up a small amount from a list of services that escrow these small amounts for us (Google Contributor for example) with the cost clearly defined, and the option to forego seeing the content entirely. Being able to set defaults for this on browser and per-site basis would make this really smooth.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWhat matters here are intentions. Yes, pretty much every human interaction is a form of manipulating the emotional state of participants, often on an unconscious level. But most of the time people do that to facilitate win-win situations, to help each other. On the other hand, most of advertising and marketing is adversarial; companies and salespeople literally want to scam you. I think it is a reasonable stance to be against manipulation with malicious intent.