5 ms·
Of course there is no "mysterious male cabal", that's a very gross (and unfortunately common) misinterpretation of patriarchy. Patriarchy is the cultural struct
by chongli 11y ago
Of course there is no "mysterious male cabal", that's a very gross (and unfortunately common) misinterpretation of patriarchy. Patriarchy is the cultural structure which preserves and reinforces traditional gender roles. That's not patriarchy being synonymous with them, just as Buddhism isn't synonymous with the cultural practice of meditation.
- exstudent2 11y agoPatriarchy is a gendered term that implies men are in control. Traditional gender roles are reinforced by men AND women. If traditional gender roles included things like women can't vote or own property, then I could see making a case for calling that patriarchy. In the west there is no such thing though.
- chongli 11y agoPatriarchy is a gendered term that implies men are in control It implies that, given its etymology, but that is not how it is defined in the literature. Tons of idiomatic words and phrases operate that way in our culture. If I were to tell you "break a leg" as you were heading out onto a theatre stage, would you imply maliciousness or benign well-wishing on my part?
- exstudent2 11y agoI'm going by the definition in the dictionary. From http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/patriarchy http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/patriarchy Full Definition of PATRIARCHY social organization marked by the supremacy of the father in the clan or family, the legal dependence of wives and children, and the reckoning of descent and inheritance in the male line; broadly : control by men of a disproportionately large share of power
- RodericDay 11y agoDon't families in Western societies outside of, like, Quebec, "reckon descent and inheritance in the male line", via the vast majority of children adopting the surname of the father and not the mother?
- exstudent2 11y agoThey "reckon descent" by choice since it's legal to use any surname you want. Definitely not inheritance though. Children of both genders are receiving their inheritance.
- chongli 11y agoYou keep invoking the word "legal" as if it has any relevance in this discussion at all; it doesn't. Patriarchy is a structure largely enforced through social mores, not laws (though there are lots of exceptions, obviously).
- exstudent2 11y agoI continue to use the dictionary definition. Without legal enforcement there is no patriarchy.
- RodericDay 11y agolmao. I guess there's no institutional racism, or homophobia, either?
- exstudent2 11y agoMisogyny is the word you're looking for. That exists, patriarchy doesn't. Just like slavery is illegal but racism exists, gay marriage is legal but homophobia exists, there is no patriarchy but misogyny exists.
- kaybe 11y ago
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Patriarchy is a gendered term that implies men are in control. It doesn't even do that. It is an equivalent of 'God did it'. Men get better treatment: Sexism by the patriarchy. Whoops, findings were wrong, women are actually getting better treatment: Reverse sexism by the patriarchy. It is like talking with a creationist.
- ameister14 11y agoThe thing is, though, that there used to be. White male landowners and business leaders continued to pass power down to their male descendants and controlled the vast majority of political, financial and military power in the United States while denying minorities and women opportunities to gain any control. That lasted around 200 years.
- exstudent2 11y agoWhite male landowners also passed great wealth and power down to their daughters. Female offspring weren't being abandoned, they were being raised in the same upper class environment as the males and retained much more power than the vast majority of men and women of lower classes who had essentially no power. Patriarchy implies men hold some sort of privilege whereas it's really rich people that have the privilege. If all instances of "patriarchy" were replaced with "the upper class" I think we'd have much more accurate and fair representation of reality. As it stands I don't think you'll ever get the millions upon millions of poor men out there to see themselves as part of the patriarchy, because they hold no power in society.
- comrh 11y ago> Patriarchy implies men hold some sort of privilege There are plenty of things that men usually get to avoid because of their sex. The majority of sexual harassment, sexual violence, domestic abuse, pay discrepancies based on sex, the list goes on and on. All of that is even worse for lower class women and even worse then that for lower class women of color. What would you call those advantages besides privilege?
- exstudent2 11y agoYou list a lot of things that are definitely not proven. This very article is discussing the nature of the pay discrepancies based on sex. Even if we take what you say as facts, there are many things women get to avoid because of their sex (warning, as speculative as your list): incarceration, violent crime, stressful manual labor, less representation in higher ed, weakened paternity rights... I think it makes a lot of sense that differences between the sexes would offer different advantages and disadvantages. I don't see any one gender having a monopoly on advantage.