4 ms·
> I am literally a worthless view to them. Well,you don't decide your own worth in this system. Your first mistake is assuming the only usefulness they get fr
by kbenson 11y ago
> I am literally a worthless view to them.
Well,you don't decide your own worth in this system. Your first mistake is assuming the only usefulness they get from you is when you click on an ad to buy something. That's a very naive view of advertising.
- ethanbond 11y agoImplying that someone somewhere knows the real value of his/her view. The whole advertising industry is built on a very naive view of advertising.
- Nursie 11y ago>> Your first mistake is assuming the only usefulness they get from you is when you click on an ad to buy something. To the advertisers? No I'm sure they think that 'brand awareness' is useful too, only it's not, if you annoy me into noticing your brand I will deliberately not buy it.
- kbenson 11y agoI think what you think you'll do, what you swear you'll do, and what you actually do aren't necessarily always aligned. But that's also irrelevant. If they are paying to have pictures put in front of you for brand awareness, then that's what they are paying for,not ad-clicks. Assuming you can completely understand their business, strategies and intentions to the point that you can accurately judge what is best for them is not just naive, it's hubris.
- Nursie 11y agoThe fact that advertisers will use things like 'brand awareness' and other subtle ways to try to get into my brain against my wishes is, IMHO, an excellent reason for blocking.
- kbenson 11y agoThat's also a good argument for holing up in a cave somewhere and never coming out. The whole of human culture and communication is full of subtle cues and plays on how our mind works, and has been for millennia.
- Nursie 11y agoIn a way, when it comes to advertisements, I do that already. I don't watch broadcast tv, I don't read newspapers or magazines on paper, I listen to BBC radio if I listen to the radio, I have adblockers for the internet. Th world can be a quieter, calmer place when you stop letting people make sales pitches at you constantly.
- kbenson 11y agoThat's an easy decision to make when you stop letting them make the sales pitches, but still take what they offer in exchange for those sales pitches. If you stopped the advertising and didn't view the content they offered in exchange, it would be quieter, calmer and a lot more boring.
- Nursie 11y ago>> If you stopped the advertising and didn't view the content they offered in exchange, it would be quieter, calmer and a lot more boring. Not really, I already pay for my tv, music and radio directly (tv license, streaming services etc) so I don't have to be advertised at, and I'm seriously considering signing up for these various no-ad services for the web. It doesn't have to be more boring without advertising, in nearly all media now there are ways to enjoy great content without letting the sales pitch in. I hope we find good ways with the web too.
- kbenson 11y ago> It doesn't have to be more boring without advertising, in nearly all media now there are ways to enjoy great content without letting the sales pitch in. I hope we find good ways with the web too. My point was that it's more boring if you forego the content that has ads, and I think your use of an ad-blocker to access this content supports this position. I also hope we find good mechanisms to pay for content without advertising, but I also don't want advertising paid services to go away. It does allow a freedom of access that wasn't possible beforehand.
- rndmind 11y agoYeah I think he can determine his buying habits far better than you.
- kbenson 11y agoMy point is that it isn't always about buying habits, at least not immediately (and sometimes never). Sometimes advertising is about awareness. Sometimes that's brand awareness, but it's also issue awareness. There are ads about social issues. They are often about making sure you are aware of the organization that put the ad out in case you want to get involved/help financially, but often it's also just to raise awareness about the issue. In what way is a site showing an ad about children going hungry in America (as Hulu used to play quite often) and him not clicking on it scamming the organization that put the ad out? In what way is his blanket rejection of the ad before actually seeing it making helping that organization? As I said, a very naive view.
- Nursie 11y ago>> In what way is a site showing an ad about children going hungry in America (as Hulu used to play quite often) and him not clicking on it scamming the organization that put the ad out? It's one 'view' (well page-load, because I'm not going to view it regardless) that's going to get them nowhere that they don't have to pay for. >> In what way is his blanket rejection of the ad before actually seeing it making helping that organization? Again, they don't have to pay for me to completely ignore them. Are you trying to argue that I should watch all advertising that comes my way in case some of it is socially responsible? I'm not sure who has the more naive view here...
- kbenson 11y ago> Are you trying to argue that I should watch all advertising that comes my way in case some of it is socially responsible? No, but I think your view on advertising and the content it supports is hypocritical (because you still accept the desired content), so I thought casting it in light of a hopefully less nefarious cause might cause you to look at it more objectively. The naivety I reference is specifically in your belief that you can correctly predict the desires of multiple large and small complex business entities in their goal to advertising in front of you, and make decisions in their best interest that are against their expressed desire. There are many arguments for ad-blockers that can be put forth, but I don't believe taking the moral high-ground is a valid one. Edit: s/arguments against/arguments for/