3 ms·
> Or do we try to create the necessary conditions so that women feel safer walking alone? Taking this thought experiment a step further -- did we create the n
by Alupis 11y ago
> Or do we try to create the necessary conditions so that women feel safer walking alone?
Taking this thought experiment a step further -- did we create the necessary conditions so that men feel safer walking alone? Or did we insist men should just feel more comfortable walking alone?
Now, it's obvious the later is what transformed into our social norm; to the point where a man expressing apprehension about walking alone is often ridiculed.
It's interesting that we've built a social norm where women are often apprehensive about walking alone, often citing fears of conflict, harassment, rape, or worse - when in reality these events are about as likely to occur as someone getting hit by a bus, or a man experiencing the same events. It's almost an artificial frailty thrust upon women in our society.
- mindslight 11y ago> to the point where a man expressing apprehension about walking alone are often ridiculed Citation needed. If someone expressed apprehension about walking in a perfectly safe area for no reason, I'd tell them I was concerned for their well being. Just as if they expressed nonchalance about walking in a demonstrably dangerous area. It's called consensus.
- qrendel 11y agoI highly doubt this is the way the majority of society views male vs female gender roles in this area. Your egalitarianism is, imo, not demonstrative of the social standard on this issue.
- mindslight 11y agoEh? My point wasn't specifically egalitarian, but to address this common allusion to "men" being oppressed when they're called out on something. Calling each other out is how people keep each other in check. It sucks really bad until you're 15-25 years old and develop the self confidence to handle things in context. I doubt the people being called out for being too risky are blogging about it.
- Alupis 11y agoI believe you may have missed the point - it's not that men feel oppressed when called out on something, or that anyone is being called out at all. It's about how it's socially normal for a man to be expected to walk alone and be "OK", but the opposite is expected of women, even though the potential dangers are the same (and about as likely to occur) for both sexes.
- mindslight 11y agoBut you're making your point with an unsupported allusion, and also implying that a man being generally expected to walk alone is somehow a problem. In reality, most adults are expected to walk alone most of the time (where are the parking lot attendants?). Sometimes women get a pass on this expectation, which is primarily a benefit, although not necessarily a wanted one. To the extent this culture encourages women to be weaker and not self-actualize, how significant is this one specific thing compared to the onslaught of commercial advertising doing that exact thing to everyone in every aspect of life? Are car companies oppressing me by tell me I have to drive everywhere? And the culture which reinforces that expectation? In a sense yes. But it's counterproductive to dwell on it rather than simply filing these messages in the "fuck off" bucket.
- meej 11y agoWomen will also take most of the blame if they suffer negative consequences from walking alone at night. People say things like, "Well, she shouldn't have been walking alone at night, it's dangerous." (Perhaps another example of the artificial frailty.) It's less common for these things to be said of men when something bad happens to them when they are walking alone.