15 ms·
So can this be used as an argument against the idea that women hold fewer positions of power (and in context of HN, fewer tech positions) not because of institu
by danso 11y ago
So can this be used as an argument against the idea that women hold fewer positions of power (and in context of HN, fewer tech positions) not because of institutional/societal sexism, but because they just don't desire them?
I don't think many of the there-needs-to-be-more-diversity crowd disagree with that. Their position is more nuanced than that, and of course, to be fair, the we-can't-make-things-have-diversity crowd is unfairly pigeonholed as being shut-up-women.
But in my reading of the paper's conclusion, women have less desire for promotions and power, but it's because they see those things as causing them strife. The we-need-more-diversity crowd believes that having more women in power is one way of alleviating a positive feedback loop.
To put it another way, here's another study that could be done: Women view walking alone at night equally attainable, but less desirable.
edit: corrected mistake of "negative feedback loop" to "positive" via lexcorvus: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10272694 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10272694
- jameshart 11y agoYes, it depends if you view the difference in attitudes between sexes as an inevitable, biological distinction, or the product of a society which shapes their expectations and attitudes differently. There's certainly no 'get out of jail free' card for biological determinist sexism here.
- facepalm 11y agoIt's not a biological determination (as in biological determined desire), it is a biologically determined wider range of options. Women can bear children, men can't. This gives women the first choice to spend time with those children, and also gives them bargaining power in relationships. An option men don't usually have. Since women have more options, they can also consider more possible ways of life. That's just my take, though - but it's only a matter of time until some unbiased gender researcher (who is not predetermined to prove suppression of women) will set out to confirm it. Edit: honestly, downvotes of this comment make me laugh. Do you feel so threatened by an opinion that does not require suppression of women to explain our modern reality?
- mklim 11y ago> Women can bear children, men can't. This gives women the first choice to spend time with those children, and also gives them bargaining power in relationships. Your second sentence doesn't follow from your first. There isn't anything inherent in the ability to give birth that gives mothers "first choice" of spending time with their children forevermore or more "bargaining power" in their romantic relationships than their partner. The only thing biologically inherent to childbirth is the ability to carry and birth children.
- jazzyk 11y agoYou know perfectly well that mother's presence is ESSENTIAL to baby's proper development. Whose belly do doctors put fresh-born babies on, their fathers? And last time I checked, men can't breastfeed no matter how hard they may try.
- mklim 11y ago> Whose belly do doctors put fresh-born babies on, their fathers? I wasn't the one who downvoted you, but I think it's unfortunate that you're citing a social practice to try and establish biological fact and claiming to understand what I "know." Nothing about a distinctly female presence is necessary for a child's proper development, much less the specific woman that birthed the baby originally. All the major psychological associations that I know of support gay adoption as healthy for children. The biologically necessary thing is a loving parental presence, gender non specific. Formula exists and can be given to children, midwives existed to feed babies before that.
- jazzyk 11y agoThere is one more thing I did not mention. The 9-month-long mother-child bonding time, unavailable to the father, the midwife and whoever else. For older children , any loving adult care is fine. But the original post was about the priority the mother has, indicating post-birth.
- danharaj 11y ago> To put it another way, here's another study that could be done: Women view walking alone at night equally attainable, but less desirable. Also, women desire casual sex as much as men do (and men don't desire it as much as mass media would have you believe), but find the sex mediocre or unsatisfying, and are wary of the dangers and conflict arising from being promiscuous. It should be no surprise to anyone that women have internalized the idea that attaining power, independence, or acting on their personal desires leads to conflict. It used to be the fucking law that it would lead to conflict!
- chongli 11y agoTo put it another way, here's another study that could be done: Women view walking alone at night equally attainable, but less desirable. It's a complicated issue. To continue your example: Do we insist that women should just feel more comfortable walking alone? Or do we try to create the necessary conditions so that women feel safer walking alone?
- Alupis 11y ago> Or do we try to create the necessary conditions so that women feel safer walking alone? Taking this thought experiment a step further -- did we create the necessary conditions so that men feel safer walking alone? Or did we insist men should just feel more comfortable walking alone? Now, it's obvious the later is what transformed into our social norm; to the point where a man expressing apprehension about walking alone is often ridiculed. It's interesting that we've built a social norm where women are often apprehensive about walking alone, often citing fears of conflict, harassment, rape, or worse - when in reality these events are about as likely to occur as someone getting hit by a bus, or a man experiencing the same events. It's almost an artificial frailty thrust upon women in our society.
- mindslight 11y ago> to the point where a man expressing apprehension about walking alone are often ridiculed Citation needed. If someone expressed apprehension about walking in a perfectly safe area for no reason, I'd tell them I was concerned for their well being. Just as if they expressed nonchalance about walking in a demonstrably dangerous area. It's called consensus.
- qrendel 11y agoI highly doubt this is the way the majority of society views male vs female gender roles in this area. Your egalitarianism is, imo, not demonstrative of the social standard on this issue.
- mindslight 11y ago
- lexcorvus 11y agoI think you mean "positive feedback loop." A negative feedback loop tends to restore an equilibrium.
- caylus 11y agoI think there's a number of interpretations of the results: 1. Women suffer more "stress and anxiety", "difficult tradeoffs", "time constraints", "burden of responsibility" and "conflict with their life goals" (direct quotes from article) in the same jobs as men due to discrimination 2. Women suffer more of the above, but due to biological differences. IOW the same situations result in more stress for women than for men. 3. Women and men suffer the same amount of these but assign them higher weight in their decision-making process. IOW the same amount of stress is enough to dissuade a woman, but not a man, from taking a position, due to different life priorities.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> IOW the same amount of stress is enough to dissuade a woman, but not a man, from taking a position, due to different life priorities. As a male, I'm willing to take on much more stress if the position is a position conveying substantial power, as that increases my standing when being selected by partners. Its a hard problem to solve to put everyone on equal footing when genders (in the aggregate) seem to have different life goals (individuals are different then aggregate numbers of course).
- gearoidoc 11y ago"...increases my standing when being selected by partners." What type of partners?
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> What type of partners? Female partners seeking a relationship or sexual encounter. I'm 32, male, do well financially as well as career wise (I'm highly in demand). I still want to be desirable to the opposite sex. I'm sure its part biology, part psychology.
- 11y ago
- andkon 11y agoI love that way of summing it up: "oh it's totally possible for you to walk home at night. You might just endure much more pain and suffering for it." Another thing worth pointing out: women are socialized to believe that conflict is unladylike. For them to avoid positions that they have an expectation of generating conflict is to fit with what the patriarchy teaches.
- exstudent2 11y agoTraditional gender roles aren't synonymous with "the patriarchy". In the west women are allowed to vote, hold property... There is no such thing as the patriarchy here. People have free will and many will exercise it to choose to act in a traditional manner. There is no mysterious male cabal forcing that to happen. On a personal note, I would find it incredibly boring if men and women acted exactly the same. I recognize others may have different opinions, but I don't think anyone can say either side is "right" or "wrong".
- danharaj 11y agoNo one thinks the patriarchy is a merely legal system enforced by a cabal of men. Patriarchy refers to interwoven social structures that promulgate certain ideologies, doctrines, and social customs. The nuclear family is part of patriarchy, for example. Also, actually, there is still a cabal of men in America forcing women to behave in certain ways: The systematic, coordinated campaign against women's reproductive rights.
- exstudent2 11y agoI'm not sure who you mean by "no one" but I certainly don't agree with anything you've stated. It's a pretty extreme view I think few would share.
- icebraining 11y agoWhat's extreme about it? It's just a different definition.
- facepalm 11y agoI thought it says that women desire several different things, so sometimes they prefer other things over holding positions of power. No need to call it strife, it's simply a decision between several desirable things that you can not all have at the same time. Otherwise you could also say the co-existence of chocolate muffins and blueberry muffins is causing women strife (and other people, too), because it forces them to decide.
- tomp 11y ago> To put it another way, here's another study that could be done: Women view walking alone at night equally attainable, but less desirable. I wonder why that is... After all, men are more likely than women to be assaulted (beaten up, robbed, murdered).
- kaybe 11y agoIs that corrected for gender of people walking around alone at night?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nicklaf 11y agoI doubt it. Not to mention that women are culturally more cautious about going out than are men when danger is perceived.
- tomp 11y ago> Not to mention that women are culturally more cautious about going out than are men when danger is perceived. I'm not too sure about that. Feminism has spent years encouraging women to ignore whatever dangers lurk in public, while men have been trained for centuries to help a woman in need. Conversely, men are themselves very well aware that they are the primary target of many violent man (if someone is looking for a fight, it's unlikely that they're going to choose a woman) and that they have nobody to count on if push comes to shove. Anecdotally, all of my male friends have been assaulted (before being 25), some multiple times, whereas even the worst statistics don't imply nearly as much assault of women.
- DanBC 11y ago> Anecdotally, all of my male friends have been assaulted (before being 25), some multiple times, whereas even the worst statistics don't imply nearly as much assault of women. Are you restricting this to assaults in public?
- rayiner 11y agoAs someone in the "we need more diversity crowd" I think the article is consistent with that position. At the end of the day, even if you can make it in an environment where you don't fit in, there is a level of pain and frustration that comes with that. Anecdote: My wife and I have similar careers in the same field. We're not the world's most involved parents, but I go through life with people telling me I'm an awesome dad because I change diapers and my wife goes through life with nursery school teachers wondering why she didn't dress our daughter up as a pirate when they gave us notice it was pirate day two whole days in advance. Every time a grandparent notes that it's a shame she comes home so late (while never mentioning how late I come home) is another drop in the "is it even fucking worth it?" bucket. But it would be erroneous to conclude that she "just wants it less" than I do. Rather, the social cost of her getting it is higher than it is for me.
- totalrobe 11y agoThese are great points on societal expectations of parents. On the flip side, there is still a lot of judgement against stay at home dads, who are typically just thought of as lazy or not manly enough if they stay at home with the kids, even if it makes sense because their wife has greater income potential due to chosen career/education.
- belorn 11y agoThere was recently a study in the news paper that showed men receiving worse discrimination in pay raise than women in relation to the time spent home with children. One suggested explanation to this is that women's wages are per-discriminated with the assumption that they will spend some amount of time home with children, but men spending time home with children doesn't fit the social expectations and they are instead judged as lazy.
- aidenn0 11y agoDamn but this is true. The levels of expectation involved in being a mother is ridiculous (eavesdrop on mothers talking with each other and count the usage of the phrase: "I know {I am|it makes me} a bad mother, but ..." followed by a completely innocuous parenting anecdote), and the bar for "good dad" is to be slightly more involved with your kids than a character from Mad Men.
- jessriedel 11y ago> But in my reading of the paper's conclusion, women have less desire for promotions and power, but it's because they see those things as causing them strife. Actually, the paper does not draw such a conclusion. They explicitly say that both "powerful positions have more negative consequences for women" and "women have less intrinsic desire for power and related privileges" are viable, possibly complimentary theories, and that distinguishing between these theories goes beyond this paper. > Identifying the origin of the differences between men’s and women’s professional aspirations is beyond the scope of the current research. Our findings may be the result of biological gender differences, learned preferences that have developed in response to cultural norms and gender-based discrimination, or both. In addition, supply-side factors (e.g., personal goals) and demand-side factors (e.g., gender-based backlash and discrimination) are inextricably linked.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Actually, the paper does not draw such a conclusion. They explicitly say that both "powerful positions have more negative consequences for women" and "women have less intrinsic desire for power and related privileges" are viable, possibly complimentary theories, and that distinguishing between these theories goes beyond this paper. There could be less positive consequences as well. At least in the culture I was raised in, a man's position factors more into their 'general attractiveness' than a woman's does. There are likely many different explanations as to why and I don't know which ones have evidence supporting and which ones have been shown false. Even if this isn't true at all, if men think it is true, it still means that earning promotions has more perceived benefit.
- Spooky23 11y agoLots of men are programmed/driven to want to be the boss. I'd like to ask the same questions to men who branch out to be SMEs in a particular field (say being a consultant) vs the traditional "climb the ladder" path. The reality is that with ladder climbers, the effort expended is usually expensive relative to the reward.
- randyrand 11y agoThe reason women have different life goals is not because they want to have different life goals, but because society forces them to have different life goals /s I mean, maybe there's some truth to that argument. But it's really stretching the idea of forced. At some level, everything we do is forced. Do we even have free will?