3 ms·
Having read many of these reports over the years, this one seems more manifesto than security report. It is full of carefully controlled language meant to appe
by sandworm101 11y ago
Having read many of these reports over the years, this one seems more manifesto than security report. It is full of carefully controlled language meant to appease a very specific audience: politicians and members of various agencies.
A huge amount of space is dedicated to tenuous ties between physical military activities and espionage on the assumption that all chinese agencies are coordinating with each other, that the Chinese are just better at conspiracy than any US operation. No actual intelligence officer would ever describe China in that way. It's a patchwork of poorly-connected operations all trying to put on a good show for the bosses, much the same as US intelligence agencies.
Certain key phrases suggest political motive. As example, the phrase "China’s ... military grade signals intelligence Unit" caught my ear. "Military grade" doesn't mean much in infosec. It does mean something to lifelong service members who labour under the assumption that military structures just do things better than civilian organizations. In some fields "military grade" is actually a bad thing, a reference to products built to conform to rarely-updated procurement standards. It's like still selling floppy disks because the computer on the stealth bombers haven't been updated in 20 years. The phrase appears right at the start of the takeaways section, right where most senior officials will probably start reading.
The drilling down upon a few people, to the point of tracking a man's movements and finding the bike he offered for sale, certainly plays into current US national security desires. Targeted killings based on poor intel is a big chip on the military shoulder these days. They aren't happy about it. So peppering a document with a few grains of seemingly accurate and specific intel about individuals is a good trick to win people over. The excessive reliance on google maps is just eyecandy. This gives the false impression of validity, a false suggestion that the rest of the report is based on equally detailed and reliable intel. if this were such intel, it wouldn't be released publicly.
the pdf: http://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/454298/Project_CAMERASHY_ThreatConnect_Copyright_2015.pdf http://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/454298/Project_CAMERASHY_Threa...
- jgome 11y agoIt's as if China was the universal scapegoat for infosec people in the US... Wait, this is a known fact in infosec circles.
- sandworm101 11y agoA scapegoat would be innocent. I doubt even the Chinese would argue they haven't done anything. That's much of the problem generally and with this document specifically. If you latch onto things and investigate them to death you will in time run across actual wrongdoing. The danger is then that you cherry-pick these truths and spread them to each and every situation, giving the appearance of overwhelming wrongdoing. I think the people behind this document have done this knowingly.