3 ms·
Replacing the code in the shared repository doesn't mean he transferred the copyright to them. When you contribute to a project, you still own the copyright, yo
by icebraining 11y ago
Replacing the code in the shared repository doesn't mean he transferred the copyright to them. When you contribute to a project, you still own the copyright, you just provided a licensed copy, and that project must still comply with it.
- uxp 11y agoThis is correct. For an arbitrary and hypothetical example, imagine that Linus woke up yesterday and decided to convert the Linux kernel to an Apache licensed project. The long and almost impossible task would be to contact each and every contributor to the Linux kernel and ask for the permission to change the license of their contribution. The "short" and "easy" task would be to write a new kernel and replace all of Linux with it, applying the new license. The old Linux kernel would still be a GPL project, but moving forward any contributions would need to be Apache licensed. It appears that the latter example is somewhat like what happened here. The old Oh-My-Fish project was some licensed project. It could have even been a WTF Public License[0] that _did_ allow contributors to fork and remove attribution. At some point, all the code in the repo was replaced with new code under the MIT license that served the same purpose, and the repo's name was changed. Moving forward, someone continued to merge in the new code to the old repo and tried to remove attribution to the new code, breaking the new code's license. The Oh-My-Fish project could have done a classical fork, severing ties with the Wahoo project just before the merge of the re-written code happened and continue to work in isolation, but it seems that they did not. [0] http://www.wtfpl.net http://www.wtfpl.net
- Sephiroth87 11y agoWhich is what happened to VLC, moving from GPL to LGPL. which took an incredible amount of work... http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/How-to-properly-relicense-a-large-open-source-project http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/How-to-properly-relice...
- jimmy123 11y agoSo if a contribution changes the LICENSE file without having every contributor agreement, won't this be an invalid LICENSE change? From what I heard about the discussion, it seems like the LICENSE file has been altered by Jorge without all the OMF's contributors agreeing upon.
- justinlardinois 11y agoIt's invalid only if the license change is inconsistent with the original license. That's why, for example, converting a project from MIT to GPL is fine, because doing so doesn't violate the terms of the MIT license.
- tankenmate 11y agoThere is also a school of thought that says once you have broken the conditions you would need to re-license the work and this might require a new negotiation; I don't think I've ever seen this line of argument tested in court however.
- TallGuyShort 11y agoThat's fair - although I can't imagine letting someone rename my project and deciding to collaborate on it together while still trying to retain my own copyright notice on files. I hope we hear the other side of the story. My point is just that the MIT license itself isn't necessarily the issue here.
- icebraining 11y agoThat's fair - although I can't imagine letting someone rename my project and deciding to collaborate on it together while still trying to retain my own copyright notice on files. I don't understand, why not? That's in fact what usually happens; projects usually have a list of contributors, providing attribution. For example: https://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/CREDITS https://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/CREDITS
- TallGuyShort 11y agoThe collaboration model of the Linux kernel is not remotely what I think the context describes. But like I said - perhaps reality is different - I still hope to hear the other side.
- charles2013 11y agothis hn comment links to a github comment (from the other side) that was deleted by the usurper: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10273780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10273780
- TallGuyShort 11y agoThanks. There's this too: https://github.com/derekstavis/diary-of-a-stolen-repository/commit/e58087908f2e84a998c2ebe4ffcf36d2f8193fe4 https://github.com/derekstavis/diary-of-a-stolen-repository/...