4 ms·
The thing to bear in mind about banks is that nowadays they are really computerized service companies that happen to specialize in finance. Competent tech isn't
by simonh 11y ago
The thing to bear in mind about banks is that nowadays they are really computerized service companies that happen to specialize in finance. Competent tech isn't just a competitive edge, it's fundamental to being able to operate at all.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y ago> about banks ... competent tech isn't just a competitive edge, it's fundamental to being able to operate at all. Automobiles are going along that curve too. Maybe this whole VW scandal is an indication of this change? edit and the Toyota firmware scandal in 2013 has similar implications: http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-toyota-damages-20131026-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-toyota-damage...
- thomnottom 11y agoThat may be true of the largest banks, but there are hundreds of others that are running on fairly incompetent tech. Either way, external audits have been a part of them for much longer than the computerization has been.
- branchless 11y agoI've worked in two of the biggest US banks for years and I can confidently say both important departments were far from completely understood by most people working there, let alone outsiders doing an audit. Most of the complexity is in the messages passed between systems. In a code audit it's fine to remove sending tag X by system A but then you find out when you hit prod system B used tag X and now it's not there which causes a problem in system C. And that would be a simplified example. I'd be disturbed by any outsider claiming they understand the dynamics of multiple systems with millions of lines of code which often have feedback loops.
- SEJeff 11y agoHonest question, have you ever worked for a bank? Many still run on AS/400 mainframes in the backends. Knowing what I know, that comment actually couldn't be further from the truth. Banks are insanely risk adverse, and rightfully so. If it works perfectly, they absolutely will not change it, even if the newer shinier tech has real benefits. Source: I don't work for a bank, but have worked in electronic trading for the past 8 years and work directly with the (in)competent tech teams from other banks to clear and reconcile trading bits.
- lettergram 11y agoUsing AS/400 systems would make them a computer service company. I actually work at a bank (developing apps) and we use a massive COBOL system for a lot of data. However, we also have a massive Hadoop cluster (much larger than the COBOL systems, and firewalls everywhere. Banks might not be the most competent at web programming, but they higher a ridiculous number of awesome security folks. I would still put them behind Apple or Google in their given domains, but many banks have pretty robust technical systems for their domain.
- Margh 11y agoEvery bank I've ever been with has had a pathetic limit on its online banking passwords. One of them (NAB) was limited to something like 10 characters and only numbers and letters. Maybe that's changed recently but still, firewalls won't help you when somebody brute forces your users' passwords in 10 minutes.
- pc86 11y ago> Many still run on AS/400 mainframes in the backends. Are you implying that using old technology makes it somehow incompetent? I don't know about you, but I absolutely do not want my financial institutions to be running their risk analysis software in Node just because someone wants to try it out.
- SEJeff 11y agoNope. I'm implying that they don't use the latest and greatest or "best tech". I'm agreeing with your opinion and having worked with the tech teams of banks am confirming it as truth via firsthand experience.
- bostonpete 11y agoSo which part of simonh's comment were you saying couldn't be further from the truth? I didn't see anything in his comment about the latest and greatest or "best tech".
- 11y ago