4 ms·
You list things which proprietary software does way better than free software. I remember when the list was the other way around – i.e. people would list thing
by teddyh 11y ago
You list things which proprietary software does way better than free software. I remember when the list was the other way around – i.e. people would list things that free software could now do, which were not very many at the time. It’s interesting that this relationship has now been reversed, and people, like yourself, now instead list the things which proprietary software can do better.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's interesting if true. It's going in that direction, too. However, I think the list is still the same: most tasks have proprietary applications that do it better with OSS mostly trying to clone them and more rarely innovating past them. I mean, MS Office vs OpenOffice? VMS or NonStop clustering vs whatever's on Linux? Windows or Mac OS vs GNOME? Most OSS just sucks compared to best proprietary stuff. It still can't do better. So, proprietary tools are the ones that OSS is still judged by. Certain categories, esp in infrastructure, have OSS kicking serious butt. The dynamic works the opposite way. Even stronger are the hybrids of proprietary and OSS that make the argument less meaningful. Many of us have predicted that hybrids would smash both with some evidence of this in cloud sector. OSS still isn't in that dominant position in general, though.
- jlarocco 11y agoI don't think the situation has reversed at all, and in fact open source has grown tremendously. There's more open source and free software, of higher quality, than any other time in the past. Commodity software like operating systems and web browsers are now dominated by open source. My point is that despite the growth, there are still many, many areas where the open source offerings are pretty lame and noncompetitive (if they even exist). Open source has never been very competitive in any of the areas I mentioned.
- teddyh 11y agoI think you completely misread my comment.