4 ms·
I sincerely doubt that. Please remember that the engine control software is already there, doing exactly the same thing in normal operation: adjusting the eng
by mpweiher 11y ago
I sincerely doubt that.
Please remember that the engine control software is already there, doing exactly the same thing in normal operation: adjusting the engine settings to produce optimal results for the current driving situation. For example, the mix should certainly be different when the car is stationary (sitting at an intersection), than when accelerating or going full throttle.
There is nothing underhanded about this, quite the contrary, it is a Good Thing™.
Once you have knobs to turn, the temptation to turn them just a little too far is always great, especially if you have conflicting goals. On the one hand, you are supposed to reduce CO2 emissions, which having great mileage does, on the other hand you are supposed to reduce NOX emissions. So you fiddle.
And car companies have always fiddled with any knob they could to get performance and always pushed it as far as they could. For example, this particular problem has been known for some time and was tolerated, see http://www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article146711288/Die-Bundesregierung-kannte-die-Betrueger-Technik.html http://www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article146711288/Die-... or http://blog.fefe.de/?ts=ab029b73 http://blog.fefe.de/?ts=ab029b73 (German). Furthermore, manipulating the catalytic converters has also been long-standing industry practice, I found a Toyota forum post complaining about the practice from 2003, also in German: http://www.toyota-forum.de/threads/kat-schaltet-unter-vollast-aus.27911/ http://www.toyota-forum.de/threads/kat-schaltet-unter-vollas... However, I remember those discussions from the late 80ies and early 90ies.
So if everyone is doing it (they are) and have been for a while (they have) why now and why Volkswagen? Your guess is as good as mine, but the EPA needed a win after some bad publicity, and going after a US manufacturer probably wouldn't have been quite as politic.
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-09-22/dear-volkswagen-was-your-biggest-mistake http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-09-22/dear-volkswagen-was...
Also remember that even one single Barbecue grill or wood-fired stove/fireplace (even the "green" pellet-based ones) emits more of the pollutants in question than a thousand of these cars. So maybe a little perspective may be in order...
UPDATE: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10265534 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10265534 has more links indicating how widespread this is (apparently all the french car manufacturers)
- learc83 11y ago>Also remember that even one single Barbecue grill or wood-fired stove/fireplace (even the "green" pellet-based ones) emits more of the pollutants in question than a thousand of these cars. So maybe a little perspective may be in order... If we we're talking about the same study, the 1,000 cars thing is talking only about particle pollutants not C02 and NOX. Also that study had to tweak the numbers a bit to get to 1,000 cars. They said that wood burning stoves produce 150g of particle pollutants per 4 hours. While new cars only produce 0.15g per 30 kilometers driven. A car will normally drive much more than 30 kilometers in 4 hours. >(even the "green" pellet-based ones) A quick look here http://www2.epa.gov/residential-wood-heaters/fact-sheet-summary-requirements-woodstoves-and-pellet-stoves http://www2.epa.gov/residential-wood-heaters/fact-sheet-summ... shows that as of this year all residential wood heaters have to emit no more than 4.5g of particle pollutants per hour. So either all new wood burning stoves are illegal or you can in fact buy "green" wood burning stoves that produce way less particle pollutants per hour than 1,000 cars. Edit: This link http://www.burningissues.org/comp-emmis-part-sources.htm http://www.burningissues.org/comp-emmis-part-sources.htm Shows that the average pellet burning, (and even EPA certified) wood burning stoves release much, much less than 150g of particle pollutants per hour.
- mpweiher 11y ago>A car will normally drive much more than 30 kilometers in 4 hours. A car is usually stationary for those 4 hours.
- learc83 11y agoThat's true, but arbitrarily picking 30km for the car and 4 hours for the car is useless. The only reason they did it is so they can say it pollutes as much as 1,000 cars. You'd need to look at average km driven per day and avg time used per day for the stove. You'll note that they are also comparing old, non EPA certified wood burning stoves with modern EPA certified cars.