3 ms·
I have mixed feelings about this. I mean, yeah, open source would definitely alleviate this issue. I don't know enough about the state of car industry software
by danso 11y ago
I have mixed feelings about this. I mean, yeah, open source would definitely alleviate this issue. I don't know enough about the state of car industry software (if Honda is par for course...I'm guessing, based on my new car...not that great?) but I imagine there would be unintended consequences that make OSS a difficult pill to swallow for carmakers. But sure, if it's feasible, make them do it.
...But my objection is that there seems to be many other ways that this problem could be solved...For example, perhaps the certification process should be slightly more rigorous than "self certification"? Obviously, testing is cumbersome if the EPA can only test "10 to 15 percent" of new cars...on the other hand, it sounds like WVU engineers were able to discover it accidentally without touching the software...which is how a lot of effective engineering testing manages to be done despite black box systems.
Yeah, making software transparent is almost always a good thing...but if the test has the kind of predictable characteristics such that programmers can seemingly hard code the parameters...Is it really easier to move an entire industry to the open source paradigm than to design a more robust test?
And not to throw too much pity on the regulators...but they were dealing with an exceptionally committed adversary. It's horrible how GM's culture allowed the ignition switch defect [1] to go unrecalled until a dozen people died in such senseless ways...but the ignition switch defect was a result of well-intended, if ultimately incorrect tradeoffs in the engineering process. And the deaths were far enough apart, and their cause not certain enough, for good-hearted engineers to have a "well, someone above my pay grade is dealing with this" mentality.
But VW's situation...it's hard to imagine how the bad code came about without active intent by everyone who touched and tested that code. It's one thing for a huge company to have the kind of bureaucratic stagnancy that leads to tragic inaction...it's something else for them to commit to breaking the law in such an obvious way.
[1] http://www.npr.org/2014/03/31/297312252/the-long-road-to-gms-ignition-switch-recall http://www.npr.org/2014/03/31/297312252/the-long-road-to-gms...
edit: It really just seems the OP is throwing a bunch of assertions together, with software being the most mysterious and therefore the most obvious scapegoat. The advocate/technologist most prominently featured doesn't make cogent arguments (though maybe he was misquoted?).
The following quote from Mr. Moglen is so nonsensical that it could only make sense to people whose understanding of computers seems very limited:
> “Software is in everything,” he said, citing airplanes, medical devices and cars, much of it proprietary and thus invisible. “We shouldn’t use it for purposes that could conceivably cause harm, like running personal computers, let alone should we use it for things like anti-lock brakes or throttle control in automobiles.”
Huh? If software shouldn't be allowed to run personal computers, because PCs can cause harm...then...huh?
- etherealmachine 11y agoI've seen a lot of comments on this topic discussing the issues manufacturers might have with releasing their code as "open source". I say odd because it's orthogonal to the issue here. No one (not even the EFF) seems to want to force auto makers to open source their code - not even if you use a bastardized meaning of open source like Microsoft's "Shared Source". What most articles I've seen propose is instead that it not be a felony to copy, reverse engineer and then inspect the code. Some articles have mentioned letting regulators inspect code, but most stick to a simple request - remove the DMCA Anti-Circumvention protection for automobile software. It's disconcerting to see a relatively simple request be pushed into straw-man territory of requiring all code be open sourced.
- danso 11y agoOf the DMCA issue, I definitely agree. If that's the main obstacle preventing a more transparent way to scrutinize automakers' software (among the many other kinds of software the DMCA negatively impacts)...it's hard to see the downside of fixing the law.
- crisnoble 11y agoI assumed the quote was with regards to closed source software and read it as "We should't use [closed source software] for [anything]"