2 ms·
Interestingly ol' Marx tried to differentiate between use and exchange. He called it value, but i suspect it could easily translate into the utility of modern e
by digi_owl 11y ago
Interestingly ol' Marx tried to differentiate between use and exchange. He called it value, but i suspect it could easily translate into the utility of modern economics.
Sadly he seemed to have managed to talk himself into circles trying to argue that labor was the source of value, and therefore capitalists were labor exploiters.
Because of this he ended up mixing use and exchange value when talking about production machines, to try to show that said machines didn't provide any more value output than was initially put into making it.
I suspect that once one correct for that, by for example making machines into labor amplifiers, Marx's writings have, given the circumstances and time it was written, some serious insights into the workings, and pitfalls, of capitalism (most people barely touch volume 1, but volume 3, published by Engels after Marx death, holds a stern warning about the effects of finance capital).
Using that as a springboard to bootstrap some other kind of society may well be futile however.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Interestingly ol' Marx tried to differentiate between use and exchange. Well, of course they're different. It does seem that Neoclassical economics is fundamentally structured upon a series of misdirections that benefit capitalists: * Blurring use and exchange value. * The non-existence of money in neoclassical models. * The non-existence of banks or other credit intermediaries in neoclassical models. * Even the non-existence of profit in neoclassical models ("perfect competition") Pretty much any kind of element of an economic model that could be used to analyze the source of profit, in fact, is just handwaved away under the heading "assumptions".
- digi_owl 11y agoSteve Keen have some lovely lines in his presentations about those assumptions. https://www.youtube.com/user/ProfSteveKeen https://www.youtube.com/user/ProfSteveKeen