3 ms·
I think it's important to note the strange duality of this moment: 1. This is a cambrian explosion of open-source infrastructure tools 2. This is the dark age
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
I think it's important to note the strange duality of this moment:
1. This is a cambrian explosion of open-source infrastructure tools
2. This is the dark ages of open-source UI
I think it's important to be aware that on this front the Open Source movement has completely stalled. When I was in College, I used Abiword, Evolution, and Rhythmbox. Now those things have been replaced for me with Google Docs, Gmail, and Amazon Music.
I love the web, it's incomparable for convenience, data protection, and access on multiple devices. But it is fundamentally at odds with Open Source software. Back in the day of desktop software, you could throw a tarball on the web and people could use your stuff without any real handholding. In order for people to use a web service you write, you have to maintain a server instance. It's just not worth it for me, random open source web service author, to maintain a server for millions of you, random open source software users. It's time and it's money for very little direct benefit to me.
And on app stores, it's pretty bad too. Maintaining a reviewed and updated app in an app store is a huge job, and not something a casual contributor to an open source GUI is going to want to do, just to have access to their branch of an app. And I'm not even sure Apple will let you submit an identical app with just one little feature changed.
This will change... the endgame is something like Ethereum, and the currentgame is maybe something like Heroku Button, but there is still a lot of infrastructure to build to make it as easy to maintain an open source web app as it is to maintain a desktop app.
And in the meantime, Open Source UI is just going to languish a bit. That's OK, it's just where we are in the history of the web. But it's going to get a lot better in the not too distant future.
- skybrian 11y agoSandstorm seems like another good possibility.
- bad_user 11y agoMy desktop is Linux and I still use LibreOffice, VLC and Thunderbird. And I also used Google's Docs, Calendar, Gmail and Music, but I've cut off my Gmail / Calendar usage due to their poor implementation for standards, having migrated from Google Apps to FastMail. I'm also paying for a Dropbox subscription because they are the only major cloud storage provider with native support for Linux and even though some clients exist for Google Drive I can't use a solution that doesn't want me as a customer; but enough ranting. I don't agree with you because the browser is ubiquitous and the web is open and based on standards. And you don't actually need a server to do interesting things in the browser. Quite the contrary, because of modern browsers, a majority of people with a PC have access to a potent development environment. And then the difference between the web and app stores is like night and day.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoIt's true, you can do a lot without a server! And I think where we're headed there's a lot happening in-browser. But there are still parts of most workflows where a little server work makes sense, and that's the bottleneck. We can't have an open source web app workflow until the entire develop/deploy workflow can be forked with a couple button presses. As long as there's one single part of that chain that needs to be done by hand, we won't have a rich pool of open source web software users. You're right though that if you're willing to use Desktop software there's still a bunch of good software out there. I'm just not interested in desktop software anymore.
- pjc50 11y agoThe main advantage of OSS is for developers and power users, who are able to understand, modify and engage with the software itself. From the pure end-user point of view, it doesn't have this advantage. Then there's the question of "customer acquisition". Low-commitment people don't seek out the best software, they have a range of options thrown at them and they pick one. Hence the current business model for startups: take people's personal data and sell it so you can spend the money on advertising your free service to them. "You can't compete with free" is a double-edged sword: libre non-exploitative software has to compete with "free to play" software that charges with your privacy and exposure to adverts.