2 ms·
> If the Russians attack the Germans... why is that a problem for the US? There is this treaty we signed in 1949 called the North Atlantic Treaty (https://en.w
by smacktoward 11y ago
> If the Russians attack the Germans... why is that a problem for the US?
There is this treaty we signed in 1949 called the North Atlantic Treaty (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Treaty), in which we promised the Germans (and the other signatory nations) that we would consider an attack on them as an attack on ourselves. That promise is what underpins NATO, the alliance that is the foundation of American strategy in Europe.
We could tear that treaty up because the world is different now, but don't kid yourself that doing so wouldn't be a big deal. It would be a huge deal, arguably the biggest deal in European politics since the formation of the EU (and maybe even before that). And it would lead other nations we have signed treaties with to start wondering if we're going to be backing out of those too, weakening or terminating those relationships as well. Such fears could start a domino effect that unravels our security arrangements worldwide.
I tend to agree that these relationships need to be rethought -- I thought the 1990s push to expand NATO to include Ukraine, for instance, was irresponsible in that it rekindled the old Russian fear of being encircled by enemies -- but modifying or unwinding them will be a very, very delicate process, not to be undertaken lightly.
- tsotha 11y ago>There is this treaty we signed in 1949 called the North Atlantic Treaty (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Treaty), in which we promised the Germans (and the other signatory nations) that we would consider an attack on them as an attack on ourselves. That promise is what underpins NATO, the alliance that is the foundation of American strategy in Europe. Which made perfect sense during the cold war. What doesn't make sense is we're still in NATO, or even that NATO exists at all. We should definitely leave the organization. >It would be a huge deal, arguably the biggest deal in European politics since the formation of the EU (and maybe even before that). Oh, absolutely. The Europeans would be really upset, since they'd have to spend more than 2% on their own defense. But... that's not really my problem, is it? How big is the Russian economy compared to the combined economy of the non-US NATO countries? If the Russians are in a position to dominate Europe from the position of relative economic weakness, who's fault is that? Of course we should give them time to build their strength, so I'd wait six or seven years before striking the flag. That's plenty of time.
- cema 11y agoYou refer to "the 1990s push to expand NATO to include Ukraine", what is that about?