6 ms·
Why the Rich Are So Much Richer
- curtis 11y agoI thought this part was interesting: So what’s really going on? Something much simpler: asset managers are just managing much more money than they used to, because there’s much more capital in the markets than there once was. As recently as 1990, hedge funds managed a total of $38.9 billion. Today, it’s closer to $3 trillion. Mutual funds in the US had $1.6 trillion in assets in 1992. Today, it’s more than $16 trillion. And that means that an asset manager today can get paid far better than an asset manager was twenty years ago, even without doing a better job.
- crpatino 11y agoI find it hard to believe that there are 2 orders of magnitude more goods and services being bought and sold in the economy that 25 years ago. Rather, the complexity of financial instruments is the one that has gone up and up, but there's not that much more real wealth to back it up. If that is the case, the short answer would be "because of inflation".
- unclebucknasty 11y agoExactly. Much of it is just leverage and financial engineering. Create derivatives of derivatives until you're essentially divorced from any underlying real asset. Still, it's all counted.
- da02 11y agoPardon my ignorance of economics, but does US/FED policy and trillion dollar deficits have anything to do with this? Along with other countries printing more money? I remember reading Zimbabwe had the best performing stock market, but it was fueled through the "printing press". And they had no choice but to stop printing more.
- bavcyc 11y agoIt is all interconnected, but I'm not sure anyone knows 100% how. I've started studying economics; the more I learn, the more I know that I don't know.
- parasubvert 11y agoNot specifically, though indirectly. The FEDs activities are intended to counter balance the lack of economic activity and investment capital coming out of the banks after the 2008 crises left them having to unwind their debt positions globally. Someone has to keep the fuel spigot on - usually that's the government but most did the opposite (austerity) due to politics. What you're witnessing is a LOT of unused capital sitting around trying to find low risk returns. Interest rates are low so money is cheap, and there are only so many places to park capital, thus... Prices go up. Post 2008 Companies aren't investing as much in the real economy: wages, productive capital, etc. are stagnant. they're profit taking and retaining the profits. What's important to know is that while assets are trending higher historically , these are all mostly paper assets - they're indirectly tied to the real economy, and haven't completely become unhinged yet like in 2000. See http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/07/08/upshot/welcome-to-the-everything-boom-or-maybe-the-everything-bubble.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/07/08/upshot/welcome-to-the-e... Zimbabwe was a case of hyperinflation. Which is what eventually happens when you have more money than productive capacity - prices of "real stuff" go up fast. But real inflation in the U.S. and Europe is very low by historical standards. We are not going to become Zimbabwe.
- da02 11y agoThanks for clearing that up. What do you think the US govt & FED should/should not do now?
- parasubvert 11y agoI think they should keep doing what they're doing - don't raise rates or reduce the monetary base (the $ trillions they keep on the books since the crisis) until real inflation is clearly setting in. Asset prices can keep inching up so long as they're not into bubble territory (which arguably they're not yet). The economy is in a much better position but it's still underperforming and the labor participation rate is still historically down as so many exited the labor force during the 2008 crisis and ensuing layoffs. Once some inflation sets in, it's a sign the world is returning to "normal" (after 8 years!), but .. no guarantees given instability in Europe, Middle East, Oil Glut, etc. Usual disclaimers: I am not an economist, but minored in it & follow it; the economics profession has a wide diversity of opinions, though I think my views aren't particularly radical. I also think the government should be ready to invest in our crumbling infrastructure for the next downturn/crisis. The 2009 stimulus helped but was not well allocated and was too small. That said it's unlikely congress will pass any such thing for many years due to current politics.
- JuliaLang 11y agoI don't think you understand derivatives. They assist in resource allocation by applying pressure to the future value of goods, so that we have more control to hedge our risks.
- enraged_camel 11y agoYep. In other words, it's all a house of cards.
- vinceguidry 11y agoI don't. In fact, I find it very easy to believe. Now that the Internet has made it possible for anyone with an net connection to do business, goods and services can be completely made up out of whole cloth. Someone goes out and makes a brand new media franchise, call it "Bleachuto." It's a tv series about dead ninjas. This new media property can easily launch an entire cottage industry of blogs, physical goods, some of which might be affiliated with the creators, some not. All that has to happen for it to be a good or service is for money to change hands. I'd say between the internationalization of capital markets, the deepening of transportation services, and just the fact that many many more emerging economies are buying stuff now, two orders of magnitude difference might well be an understatement, it could well be three or even four.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>Someone goes out and makes a brand new media franchise, call it "Bleachuto." It's a tv series about dead ninjas. This new media property can easily launch an entire cottage industry of blogs, physical goods, some of which might be affiliated with the creators, some not. And yet the anime industry is continually going out of business?
- panic 11y agoIf people have been making profits for the last 25 years and investing them, the amount of money in the markets will increase regardless of the instruments involved. Wealth is accumulating, but people don't really know what to do with it besides giving it to someone else to invest.
- crpatino 11y agoNo, money is only numbers. If you cut down a tree, cut it in boards, cut the boards and nail the pieces into a bunch of chairs, that is value added. It did create wealth. Same, if you write a bunch of code that did not exist before, and the code is compiled and linked into a program that allows users to do stuff they could not do before (or could, but much more slowly) then there is value added. Wealth was created, even if there is no physical representation of that wealth... but it has real effects on the real world. But when people just place bets, and double-down bets, and triple-dare-you bets on whether or not some random guy is going to write a program that might or might not go viral and get a billion or eyeballs... that's not wealth creation. That is just toying with numbers. You just produce noise in the economy so that the real prices of real stuff cannot be discovered anymore.
- justinmk 11y agoPrediction markets are valuable.
- gress 11y agoSure, but the stock market is not valuable as a prediction market.
- justinmk 11y agoThat might be a sign that it's over-regulated.
- crpatino 11y agoValuable for whom, or for what? If those did what they claim to do, sure: They would help to allocate resources to invest in projects that created the most goods and services to raise everyone's standard of living. There is certainly value in that, since we all would get more and better capital goods for the same amount of investment. Sadly, this is no longer the case. I don't really know about finances, but I have seen first hand great engineering companies that got bought by assholes that did not have any money themselves, but used their dark wizardry financial tricks to leverage themselves to the ears. Then, they proceed to cut costs like there is no tomorrow, again, making the numbers in the accounting books look much better than the real health of the company, all this at the cost of gutting the mid-to-long term feasibility of the business. Finally, they go and use their lies and numbers to find a bigger sucker, and sell the company by a price even bigger than what they paid in the first place. And you know what, the whole financial industry exist to enable those fuckers to go around dishing chaos and destruction, because earning an honest profit by servicing happy customers is almost never as profitable as dilapidating in months stores of wealth that took decades to build up in the first place. It does not matter if they sell below the real value, since they did not personally invest any time or effort in accumulating the wealth, getting pennies on the dollar suits just fine.
- parasubvert 11y agoAsset prices have gone up 2 orders of magnitude; real inflation for "real" things (not financial instruments) hasn't gone up as much (80% or so). In part this is because profits have been up, therefore equities are up. Profits are up because companies aren't investing in the real economy as much since the 2008 crash. As to whether this is sustainable... PE ratios are trending higher but no where near the dot-com era levels. So it's not like equities are completely out of whack with reality.
- tsotha 11y agoYou also have to factor in QE. Low interest rates make bonds considerably less attractive, so a lot of the money that used to be in bonds has moved into the stock market chasing returns high enough to cover inflation.
- rayiner 11y agoYou're mixing up assets and yearly output. You're also ignoring the fact that real assets that always existed may be shifting from other asset classes to hedge funds.
- crpatino 11y agoI confess I am ignorant, so I don't know what you are talking about. But, I do not see that many more hard assets (I mean physical... I am sure finance has a technical definition that has nothing to do with what the intuition of lay people like myself would think) created. It does not matter if there are trillions, quadrillions or quintillions of dollars; if they had to spend it all, they would end up owning the whole planet and still not run out of money. So, it is just a matter of stroking egos and playing con games with using K-9 level math, but with much higher numbers. Ultimately, the only thing that much money is worth is to show that you have much more of it than the next person. It is all about social posturing (or if you are cynical, about manipulating other people by triggering emotional responses to the huge numbers involved).
- hglman 11y agoMy guess is its that smart phones are more valuable than the raw materials, or more valuable than a tv, a land line phone, and a hand radio are individually. So not that there are more, that they are more valuable objects.
- crpatino 11y agoTo some degree, yes. Still, there were cell phones in the 90s. Are the current smartphones that much more valuable than those early mobiles? Remember we are talking about 2 orders of magnitude here. There were also PCs, and with Word Perfect and Lotus 123 you could do almost everything you do today with the latest office suite. At least almost everything of what the average user knows how to do.
- JamesBarney 11y agoHere is some context for anyone else who is curious. A 1990 dollar is worth 1.84 dollars today because of inflation. There are about 3 times as many goods and services sold since 1990.(adjusted for inflation) [0] But real wealth has increased by 4.25x not adjusted for inflation[1]($20 trillion in 1990 to $85 trillion today) So it looks like there is 2.3x as much wealth, its valued 1.8x as highly, mutual funds manage a 2.7x larger share of net worth.(which is 18% of the household net-worth of $85 trillion) and hedge funds manage a 18x larger share of net worht.(which is 3.5% of house net-worth). It would also be interesting to see how much of this shift is due to larger amounts of wealth inequality. Specifically the wealthy have less of their net-worth in real estate, a larger share in the mutual funds, and astronomically larger share in hedge funds compared to the poor. [0] http://www.statista.com/statistics/188105/annual-gdp-of-the-united-states-since-1990/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/188105/annual-gdp-of-the-... [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a3/Graphic.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a3/Graphic.png [2] http://time.com/money/3919690/americans-total-net-worth-record/ http://time.com/money/3919690/americans-total-net-worth-reco...
- x5n1 11y agoAnd that wealth is nicely tied in the top tier of society with no chances of it trickling down to the masses. And they wonder why no one is buying anything or willing to pay for anything. It's like DMX said, stop being greedy.
- wstrange 11y agoSome good points in the article, but I am not sure I agree with all of its conclusions. CEO pay is going through the roof because of a ratcheting-up effect that has been going for years. The board brings a consultant to evaluate the CEOs pay. Said consultant is in tight with board, and is looking for their next consulting gig. Not a chance they are going to recommend a significant cut, or a performance plan that is aligned with long term (5+ year) shareholder interests. I'd like to see CEOs treated like true investors. Want to make 50 million if the company does well? Cool. Company loses money? You owe $60 million. The current status quo is all upside for CEOs - they have no skin in the game.
- badsock 11y agoI'd be happy with just a minimum vesting term for options, like 5 or 10 years. That way they're in the same boat as the rest of us schmucks who can't go golden-parachute job-hopping every few quarters. Something that would motivate them to make decisions in the interest of the company's overall future, not just the next earnings report.
- prostoalex 11y agoHow many shareholders are pursuing 5 to 10-year horizons? It seems like most shareholders today are just shareflippers, and if all the shareholders care about is next quarter's earnings report, they will inevitably hire staff that mirrors their interests. Perhaps moving long-term capital gains tax benefit from 12 months to something like 60, and taxing the rest at regular income rates would change the game.
- randyrand 11y agoThere's no reason to limit that kind of obviously beneficial practice to just the CEO. Imagine how beneficial it would be to apply it to all the employees. Company is earning money? You get your paycheck. Company is losing money? Cough up.
- lfam 11y agoSounds like a co-op.
- ClintEhrlich 11y agoThe article omits some of the basic information needed for making sense of the data: What is the composition of the one-percent? I doubt that corporate executives make up a significant percentage of the super-wealthy, despite the attention the media pays to them. If that's true, then ipso facto changes in CEO compensation cannot account for most of the structural increase in inequality over the last half century. A more likely suspect is the influence of technology, which has interlinked global markets so that the dominant players are able to extract significantly more value than in the past. Outsourcing has suppressed wages while increasing profitability, which naturally contributes to inequality. And in an interconnected global trading system, economies of scale become more and more beneficial, which consolidates resources among the top competitors in a given field. One interesting question is how the sharing economy will affect this phenomenon in the future. Will the creation of 'Ubers for everything' drive down wages even further by saturating labor markets with even more surplus human capital? Will it destabilize some of the entrenched social hierarchies in America by gutting the fortunes that legacy industries currently enjoy? Another issue worth serious thought is which kinds of inequality are most harmful to society and why. Is stratification of the middle class and the hyper-rich the primary dilemma, simply because it accounts for the greatest resource disparity on paper? Or in practice is America's social cohesion damaged more by the smaller gaps between members of the other social classes? Finally, how should concerns about inequality influence America's immigration policy? If we view the current situation as a problem, then importing more low-skilled laborers will exacerbate things. It's hardly a coincidence that the super-rich are some of the strongest advocates of comprehensive immigration reform. That may well be a desirable policy for humanitarian reasons, but we should remember the relevant externalities.
- pcurve 11y ago"I doubt that corporate executives make up a significant percentage of the super-wealthy, despite the attention the media pays to them. " I'm afraid you're wrong on this point. http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2011/10/one-percent-income-inequality-OWS http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2011/10/one-percent-income-i... Corporate executives account for almost 3rd of the top 1%, even if you exclude bankers. Throwing in bankers, and it's almost half. I agree with you on that technology and automation are the main driver in increased leverage against workers. And sadly, government and regulations failed to counteract this leverage.
- dean 11y ago"... the policies that shaped the US in the postwar era: high marginal tax rates on the rich and meaningful investment in public infrastructure, education, and technology." This is interesting in the context of the current GOP race in the States, where the candidates continually speak about how America has become weak compared to what it was in the past. It seems these kinds of policies contributed to making it strong. But these kinds of policies are anathema in GOP circles now. Ironic.
- maratd 11y agoWhen the GOP candidates are talking about "making America strong again" they are primarily talking about foreign policy, not domestic. American foreign policy under Obama has been haphazard at best, frequently angering allies and ignoring threats. They're focusing on that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- spiralpolitik 11y agoAs proposed by Thomas Piketty in Capital in the 21st Century, when "r > g" (where r = return on capital and g = rate of economic growth) the rich (those with capital) get richer. Apart from between 1930 and 1975 (which Piketty suggests were unique circumstances due to WW2) r has generally been greater than g.
- hglman 11y agoThere was an article on the projected growth of the middle class in china. If that was to hold, it would support the point. If everyone gets some linear growth to their income, those at the bottom get the most %. So the pie shifts down. If its about leveraging existing capital, then more capital means more for you and the pie shifts up.
- blueyes 11y agoTwo words: compound interest. To those that have much, much accrues. In the absence of redistributive taxes, societies become unequal because math.
- tbrownaw 11y agoExcept that this has been observed to not happen. Wealth differences between families have been observed to not compound across generations. Wealth differences between nations also don't compound across generations. So, there's clearly something that stops reality from matching that nice pretty math.
- harryh 11y agoShirt sleeves to shirt sleeves in three generations. Money is much easier to spend than to keep. And if you didn't have the discipline to earn it in the first place it's even easier.
- vikingux81 11y ago"So an unequal economy is less robust, productive, and stable than it otherwise would be." Given this is true and Stiglitz is correct, the inverse may also be true: An economy that is less robust, less productive and less stable becomes more unequal. This would create a positive feedback loop, which may seem dismal. However if thats the case then strategies and actions that break the loop by improving robustness, productivity, and stability of the economies of individuals, groups and organizations may prove effective. Examples include skills training to become more robust, infrastructure investments to improve productivity, and orienting choices to improve stability could be implemented from the individual up to global scale. Simple redistribution may prove less effective.
- x5n1 11y agoAmerica was set up by the elite for the elite, that's what liberal democracy more or less means protection of the minority from the majority so that they may prosper and create jobs for the masses who can then get a piece. It was a bunch of rich people who no longer wanted to pay taxes. So as they say, "good luck with that". What should be more often than not never is because the power structures keep things going a certain way and are hard to challenge unless the system is designed from its inception for that. As the system is running, the next thing is automation which is a junction where you can challenge power but it's already seeming like that's also going to go to the wealthy. They own the capital, they make the entire machine run. They are in a word, "untouchable". At best it seems like we'll get a compromise where we will be given a minimum income to live our menial lives with a very low level of income. But then again you don't need things to be happy. You just need time and enough resources for an relatively easy life.