3 ms·
I hear you, but personally that strikes me as unduly pessimistic. Geopolitics is not a zero-sum game, the rise of one power does not necessarily come at the exp
by smacktoward 11y ago
I hear you, but personally that strikes me as unduly pessimistic. Geopolitics is not a zero-sum game, the rise of one power does not necessarily come at the expense of another. Britain was eyeing the rising United States in 1900 as warily as the U.S. eyes China today, but the emergence of the U.S. as a world power eventually proved to be a development of great benefit to Britain.
- venomsnake 11y agoNo it didn't. It was just the least worst option. The other were USSR or the Axis. Britain was beaten hard in the two wars.
- bigdubs 11y agoThe cultural differences between the US (especially in 1900 as you say) and Britain, and the US and China today are much more significant. I don't think these two periods are comparable.
- smacktoward 11y agoI didn't say that it was inevitable that a rising China would have as good a relationship as the one that emerged between Britain and the U.S. In fact I would classify it as unlikely, precisely because America and China lack the cultural bonds. My point was more limited -- simply that waning hegemons always see rising challengers as great threats, which they don't always turn out to be. EDIT: To see how the U.S.-U.K. alliance was not necessarily the sure thing it appears to be in hindsight, look into War Plan Red (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Plan_Red https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Plan_Red). The U.S. actively maintained a strategic plan for fighting a war with Britain as late as 1939.
- classicsnoot 11y agoGeopolitics is not a 0sum game *for the US. It is absolutely a 0sum game for China.
- rrggrr 11y agoAnd what values or inalienable rights does China stand for? Self determination? Environmental protection? Protection of minorities, children, women? Perhaps... Yet there is zero evidence the rise of any world power other than the US that has brought about as much good in the world? There is evidence geopolitcs is very much a zero sum game for many nations.