3 ms·
> While some of the first type find success due to excellent craftsmanship of their works, it is the second type that normally gets in museums because the messa
by varjag 11y ago
> While some of the first type find success due to excellent craftsmanship of their works, it is the second type that normally gets in museums because the messages have cultural and historical significance.
This is a postmodern phenomenon, and art museums well predate it.
- coldtea 11y agoOnly if you just count political messages. Artists have been celebrated for their social, philosophical, metaphysical, poetic etc messages for millenia. Even renaissance artists (an era that can be extremely tacky with technique) weren't celebrated for their mere technique showcase (photorealistic skills and such BS), but for their artistic qualities (expression). Even more so later years. El Greco, Goya, etc are not celebrated because of their "excellent craftsmanship" in the conventional sense, but for the sensibilities they capture.
- varjag 11y agoWell I'm going to tread cautiously here, as it's too easy to end up sounding like a snob layperson not seeing beyond the brushstroke. But. Let's not confuse the message with expression. There's an appreciable difference in how the postmodern works are evaluated compared to the predecessors. While the latter could carry some context, a message if you will, they were and are largely celebrated for their visual, cognitive, artistic impact alone: save perhaps for occasional historic value. I'm not just talking about classic Dutch painters and alike. The modernists in fact had it sorted out, and commenced the shift from technique to expression. Yes, some of them did sometimes promote a message with their artwork, but let's face it we don't commemorate Picasso for his Communist views: he simply was that good. Now Postmodern is entirely another story. When you walk into a room at Guggenheim full of empty Kodak Carousel projectors clicking at the walls, it's quite different from the classic curated museum work of old. There's zero technique, very marginal expression, and the message which you either make up for yourself or read in the artistic statement.