8 ms·
America's Military Supremacy Is Fading
- orionblastar 11y agoIt is after all the Post-American would with the rise of the rest. The USA has had an advantage after WW2 for not having anything destroyed in the war, and being able to out produce everyone else. There came many innovations in technology. The other nations buy that technology and now make that technology because the labor is cheaper over there. The USA had a good economy in the 1990s during the startup bubble rising before it burst in 1999-2000. Good enough to build a military superiority. Sun/Oracle had government contracts to make military systems using their software. I worked as a federal contractor in 1996-1997 to help migration systems from ATCOM to MICOM to save money and move the aviation databases and systems down to the missile command base to save money and combine them so they could work on the drone program. The drone is remote controlled and not AI based, it is very effective. No risk of our pilots in using them. But the tech in other nations has caught up to match our military technology. We lost the superiority. The same with NASA, lost the advantage there due to mismanagement and mistakes. No planned replacement for the space shuttle, have to hitch a ride to the ISS with the Russians. Still using rockets to put things into space. Many one of the commercial space companies will also make a better fighter jet or something, who knows?
- codeonfire 11y agoThe 1950's through 1980's were a long four decades of wars since WW2. Any advantage going into the cold war shouldn't of carried through to the 90's. And we had little insight into soviet technology in the 80's, so who's to say the technology wasn't on par. Western culture, I think, means that technology is moved from military to public applications faster and was easier to see.
- methodover 11y ago"Still using rockets to put things into space." Is ... is there an alternative?
- nl 11y agoI think the OP was implying that the Space Shuttle (or some king of reusable replacement system) is/was better than traditional rockets. It was poorly worded if that is the case - reusable systems all use rockets and it isn't at all clear that they are better in any way.
- sudo_free_cake 11y agoProposed? yes In use? no In addition to things like the space elevator, there are some really cool projects like this, http://escapedynamics.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Escape-Dynamics-External-Propulsion-WP.pdf http://escapedynamics.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Escape-...
- aburan28 11y agoHow is America's military supremacy fading? Last time I checked we still have plenty of nuclear weapons
- fosk 11y agoMilitary supremacy means being able to effectively project power around the world. The article states that this capability is declining.
- fredgrott 11y agoUS nukes was a response at the time late 1940s early 1950s to the reality that adversaries had armies in the millions.. As the US Air and Navy became more powerful in projecting power our nuke weapons became somewhat ineffective..which explains why we signed SALT I and SALT II treaties to reduce nukes.. But even today those with millions of soldiers in armies still lack the air power and naval power to project that powerful army...
- jonnathanson 11y agoCorrect. The author also draws a distinction between "supremacy" and "superiority." The former means an overwhelming and almost unchecked ability to impose our will militarily across the globe. The latter means a comparative advantage over our would-be competitors. We are exiting an anomalous and short-lived period in history in which we enjoyed supremacy, and we are entering a period in which we will likely enjoy superiority. This is a relative decline, not an absolute decline.
- venomsnake 11y agoWill US have superiority though? The pentagon has the uncanny ability to re-fight the last war. Why is F-35 even existing - you could raise a 100 drones for the price of each (or a 1000 with economy of scale) and just saturate any defense. And you couldn't care less if you lose 99% of them if the objectives are met.
- 11y ago
- fosk 11y agoI believe that the author scratches the surface and never develops in a deeper reasoning about what we should expect from this century, what are the short and long term consequences and how they will affect global geopolitics and the current equilibrium. The article only makes a flat "rise and fall" analysis, and even when presented with the opportunity to explore more interesting arguments (US vs India/China both from a military and economical standpoint, economical repercussions of a weaker army, geo-political consequences in Europe, etc), the author never chooses to do so.
- Armisael16 11y agoI think that kind of analysis is what you use to fill books.
- douche 11y agoA U.S. carrier group, by itself, would be a top-10 navy in the world, and its carrier air wing would make a respectable national air force. Only two other nations operate aircraft carriers remotely in the same class as a Nimitz-class, and the United States has ten. No other country has the same ability to project power that the United States does. It's perhaps unprecedented in the history of the world. Perhaps its military might is reduced from Reagan-era heights, but Russia is also a shell of what the Soviet Union was, and China has not yet filled that void.
- jonnathanson 11y agoCarrier groups are an extremely important projector of power, but they are not invulnerable. See: China's significant investments in "carrier killer" missiles. Such missiles don't even need to be fired in order to be effective regional deterrants; the mere threat of a sunk carrier would give us pause in the event of an escalating situation in, say, Taiwan. The article doesn't argue that China or Russia are going to project power off the coast of New York anytime soon; merely that our relative capability to project power off of their coasts is in decline.
- gbhn 11y agoIt's also worth noting that power projection is also different because of different balances of other interests. The kinds of things other countries want to do is different, and the lengths to which the US is willing to go to affect them is different. In my opinion, these factors might be just as great or greater than relative military superiority.
- dogma1138 11y agoThis is why a carrier strike group will have Agies destroyers to combat ballistic threats, and for other threats CIWS systems do a pretty good job. Ship defense systems are quite advanced these days for the most part they can knock out anything out of the sky no matter how low or high it flies.
- hollerith 11y ago
- tsotha 11y agoThis is somewhat deliberate. We have the resources to stay on top, but we have other priorities. During the cold war we spent 10% of our GDP on the military. These days it's more like 4%. Personally I'd like to see the US pull back sharply from its global commitments. There's no reason for US troops in Germany or Japan or Korea. There's no reason for the US to get involved in land disputes in the South China Sea. If the countries involved fight it out just let us know who wins so we can update our maps.
- smacktoward 11y ago> There's no reason for US troops in Germany Russia. (see: Ukraine) > or Japan China. > or Korea North Korea. > There's no reason for the US to get involved in land disputes in the South China Sea The problem is that the U.S. has longstanding treaty commitments guaranteeing the sovereignty of several other countries in that area, such as Taiwan and the Philippines, and significant trade relationships with others, such as Vietnam. A unilateral U.S. pullout from the region would therefore send the message to other nations we have defense treaties with (such as NATO members) that we can't be trusted to stand by our treaty obligations, which would weaken those relationships substantially.
- tsotha 11y agoOh, there's a reason the Germans and the Japanese and the Koreans might want to have troops. There's just no reason for US troops to be there. WW II has been over for a long, long time. If the Russians attack the Germans, or the Chinese attack the Japanese... why is that a problem for the US? We're not trying to contain global communism or fascism. We should be a friend to freedom everywhere, but not its guardian.
- smacktoward 11y ago> If the Russians attack the Germans... why is that a problem for the US? There is this treaty we signed in 1949 called the North Atlantic Treaty (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Treaty), in which we promised the Germans (and the other signatory nations) that we would consider an attack on them as an attack on ourselves. That promise is what underpins NATO, the alliance that is the foundation of American strategy in Europe. We could tear that treaty up because the world is different now, but don't kid yourself that doing so wouldn't be a big deal. It would be a huge deal, arguably the biggest deal in European politics since the formation of the EU (and maybe even before that). And it would lead other nations we have signed treaties with to start wondering if we're going to be backing out of those too, weakening or terminating those relationships as well. Such fears could start a domino effect that unravels our security arrangements worldwide. I tend to agree that these relationships need to be rethought -- I thought the 1990s push to expand NATO to include Ukraine, for instance, was irresponsible in that it rekindled the old Russian fear of being encircled by enemies -- but modifying or unwinding them will be a very, very delicate process, not to be undertaken lightly.
- rrggrr 11y agoAbout as many major conflicts ignited from fear and desperation as from territorial ambition. 90 years of US hegemony acted as an effective firewall that prevented countless conflicts, although bloody, from becoming regional or global wars. There is no record in history of any hegemonic power, League of Nations or even knights of Camelot bringing stability and security to the world as has the US. Celebrate your new multipolar world, if thats in fact the transition taking place. But I am with Hobbes on this one... Without a Leviathan we will descend into a state of nature where life is nasty, brutish and short. On this point, history sadly agrees.
- venomsnake 11y agoThe European concert and Pax Britannica worked quite well, also for roughly a century without a major war.
- smacktoward 11y agoI hear you, but personally that strikes me as unduly pessimistic. Geopolitics is not a zero-sum game, the rise of one power does not necessarily come at the expense of another. Britain was eyeing the rising United States in 1900 as warily as the U.S. eyes China today, but the emergence of the U.S. as a world power eventually proved to be a development of great benefit to Britain.
- venomsnake 11y agoNo it didn't. It was just the least worst option. The other were USSR or the Axis. Britain was beaten hard in the two wars.
- bigdubs 11y agoThe cultural differences between the US (especially in 1900 as you say) and Britain, and the US and China today are much more significant. I don't think these two periods are comparable.
- smacktoward 11y ago
- swagv 11y agoIt's not like the 90s were glory days for the American military either.
- loourr 11y agoBut not the budget
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThe article misses the elephant in the room; the US Dollar is in trouble. To get some view into why, take a look at the emergence of the AIIB (China's equivalent of the World Bank) and take a look at the reasons why the US has been in negotiations in Iran (Just about nuclear proliferation? There's a bit more to it... http://youtu.be/hs_2zzNyP_M http://youtu.be/hs_2zzNyP_M ). In short, the strength of the US Dollar is seen by quite a few people to be based on its position in international trade, and this position is being challenged (past challenges have led to wars, but that's not going to work for much longer, unless the US intends to start WW3). If the funding base is taken away, the US military is unlikely to remain the dominant force it is today. Kind of puts the TTIP/TTP/TISA deals into a new perspective too, international deals to reassert the US position by boosting the role of big business.
- jorgecastillo 11y agoYeah I don't think so. You'd have to be a mad men to bet against the US Dollar short term (couple of decades). After that who knows!
- ZenoArrow 11y agoIt'd only take a few of the oil producing nations to start trading in a different currency. Back in the year 2000 one of those countries started trading oil in Euros. That country was Iraq. What was one of the first actions taken by the US after the US asserted control over Iraq? Replacing the Euro with US Dollars for oil sales. If one country doing this is enough to spook the US, what does that tell you? Furthermore, this has not been an isolated incident, other oil-rich countries have threatened to leave the US Dollar behind and have faced instability shortly after (Libya, Syria, etc...).
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI agree with you. Also, in addition to AIIB, I think that Russia and Japan are setting up some sort of international money clearing house. I am a USA citizen and I think it is in our best national interest to pull back a bit from the world stage. Nothing too extreme, just close a good fraction of our foriegn military bases and bring our troups home. We could still rapidly deploy if for example a close ally was invaded and needed our help. Troups returning to the USA would be very helpful in working on infrasturcture, etc. I think this would be fair to them as long as they got the same standard of living and benefits.
- bane 11y agoI disagree with this. The U.S. military has no single conventional opponent that can reasonably oppose it, anywhere in the world. Keep in mind this article is coming out after the U.S. simultaneously engaged in two decade-long wars simultaneously while still maintaining continuous presence in Asia, Europe and with hardly a blip on the economic radar in the U.S. During WW2, the U.S. shifted virtually the entire economy to a war footing, and outproduced land, sea and air vehicles and munitions of several other combined nations. The U.S. spends a remarkably small fraction of GDP on war goods at present, but history shows that when it gears up in one direction, it can rapidly turn into a highly militaristic society. In fact, the U.S. military is optimized for external operations and force projection, home turf is not the kind of advantage it was throughout history. There is no tactical position on the planet that a conventional military can assume that the U.S. cannot effectively target. Americans have absolute dominion of the skies, with a multi-phased air force that can erode even highly fortified air defense systems. American missiles can be launched from ships, submarines, mobile launchers and so on and can strike, soften or destroy armored stationary armored targets. American armor is so advanced, and numerous, that it can fight in the middle of a chem-bio weapons attack, while on the move, take multiple armor piercing rounds, and still fight. American foot soldiers are heavily armed and armored. They're among the best trained in tactical fighting, and can fight in open battles to urban landscapes equally well. In unit on unit fights, the American military almost always absolutely dominates. The Officer corps is trained at some of the finest military schools in the world, with lessons on logistics, strategy and tactics that span lessons learned from thousands of years of history. The schools are so good, the other countries send their officers there for training. Americans are pragmatic fighters, without doctrine of fighting to the last man or always pushing ahead. It doesn't waste time training for tough-man parlor tricks. There's minimal shame in retreating because it just means you can fight again tomorrow. On the flip side, the U.S., despite having huge borders, is a virtual fortress. Two huge oceans means any non-American invader needs to project massive military power around half the planet, something no other country can do. Once here, the U.S. is packed full of military bases with something like more than a million active duty soldiers, most of which are veterans of overseas campaigns -- the U.S. has almost been continuously at war since its founding. There's around another 800,000 reservists. Something like between 30-40% of all Americans have been in the military at one time or another. Beyond that, there's another 70million fit for duty and there are as many guns in America as there are people. This is a military of volunteers, people chose to join. The problem is that conventional wars aren't what's likely to happen. The U.S. maintains a massive conventional force, but also has decades of practice fighting unconventional wars against guerrilla-style tactics. It's not optimized for it, so it doesn't do it very well, but it's further along that route than virtually anybody else -- for example, American air power now has a non-trivial percentage of unmanned, long-dwell, drones, that are increasingly armed and capable. The need to fight against conventional air forces is dwindling. Going forward, the U.S. is going towards unmanned drones, either autonomous or piloted from thousands of miles away, exoskeleton and armored enhanced ground troops, autonomous tactical walking ground units, auto-aiming and firing weapons, enhanced mesh sensor networks, directed energy weapons, rail guns, higher precision munitions, hyper-spectral computer vision enhanced vision systems, live tactical coordinating AI, advanced 3d models of entire countries down to cm-level precision, simulation systems that can predict everything from enemy sniper locations to how many GPS satellites you're nav system will be able to see from this position in a city, blocked by these buildings, 12 hours into the future. The U.S. is conceivably 3-5 generations ahead of everybody else on the planet in terms of technology and techniques and is on a path of bringing to bear this future technology without having to put a single American on foreign soil. Even U.S.-level advanced militaries like Britain and Australia are no longer able to keep up. Hyper-advanced economies like South Korea license 2-generation older fighter planes, which are outfitted with lesser avionics and radar systems. The U.S. still struggles against asymmetric tactics, but its catching up fast. SOF units are developing tactics and are training specifically to counter asymmetric enemies. A combination of intelligence and precision strikes, theories of human organization and communications, anti-enemy-logistics, anti-improvised, anti-etc. If the U.S. can cover conventional and asymmetric warfare reasonably well, there's no force on the planet that can withstand it, not conceivably in the next few generations. The rise of other powers is more likely to bring Americans out of the complacency of the 90s, and reinvigorate military development and maintenance, not threaten it.
- jleyank 11y agoThe US/China relationship going significantly south would have, umm, interesting consequences. Would Wal-Mart survive? How much better would the US financial position be if all of the Chinese holdings are abrogated? What is China's political stability if the flow of money was interrupted? How can the west resurrect a tech manufacturing sector (or any manufacturing sector)?... It goes on and on. Given the inter-connectedness of the world vs. the isolationism/autarky of the 30's the impact of conflict is magnified. Yes, countries could recreate the various "changes" of the 20th century, but that's not a quick process. And Paul Kennedy would (has?) argue that the US today and Britain in 1900 are quite similar. Edit/addition: The US political system is currently broken. However, it has shown amazing resiliency when faced with an external threat. I would be willing to bet that few will care what a Kentucky clerk says if it's Sputnik all over again. And there's several strong military traditions in Europe which bear remembering.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- reustle 11y ago> Would Wal-Mart survive? You seem to say this hinting at trading with China would be significantly reduced. I think we need to worry less about Walmart and more about where everyone will get their stuff