3 ms·
It's not even the position expressed in the parent comment.
by klodolph 11y ago
It's not even the position expressed in the parent comment.
- steveklabnik 11y agoIt is how my original parent perceived it, and perceptions matter. I wouldn't work on Rust if I didn't think it was important and a step forward, but even technologies with flaws (read: all of them, Rust has flaws too) are worth using, depending on your situation. Trade-offs are the heart of engineering.
- klodolph 11y agoPerceptions matter, but language choice is a very personal issue and I've noticed that people can get very defensive when they perceive attacks on their language of choice (such as C++) or support for a language they hate (such as PHP). We should continue to talk about language choice because it's important, and we should avoid getting into pissing matches when we do it. I'm convinced that in order to make this work, we have to be more generous in how we perceive other people's comments.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI agree. I have an example. I'm an opponent of both C and C++ who goes so far as to call them garbage. In some ways, I throw them in the same camp. However, C++ supporters consistently argued that it was a vast improvement over C even in safety and most C-like problems in came from "using C++ like C." It took a while but a few eventually supported that position with specific evidence (example below) that made me adopt their position. Not to mention same empirical studies I cite showed C++ apps having less defects than C apps. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10208786 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10208786 So, there's an example where I had to step back, assume other person has intelligent reasons, and let the person show them with good results coming out of it. I still have a use of "C/C++" in these discussions but now do it less often due to superior safety over C of modern C++ development. New standards mean I'll probably be hit with a similar conversation again lol.