4 ms·
Top talent wants a low valuation so that stock options can provide a big payout.
by bryanlarsen 11y ago
Top talent wants a low valuation so that stock options can provide a big payout.
- beambot 11y agoPlus: Anyone who is "top talent" is probably well aware of the negative effect of liquidation preferences on employee common stock value in an acquisition (the topic of the article). So $1B valuations with heavy liquidation preferences are not a good thing to these folks.
- aqme28 11y agoHowever liquidation preferences are opaque to candidates, so "top talent" just has to assume there are liquidation preferences on all companies.
- beambot 11y agoThose terms are very material to a candidate's compensation package; maybe they should be made known. (Honesty and transparency?!)
- flog 11y agoSo should this mean talent should be discounting equity when negotiating deals with still-private companies? If so, how much?
- neelm 11y agoYes. Not always easy to answer. Some factor of revenue growth, margins, how much capital the company has already raised, understanding the burn rate, how much has been spent vs dry powder, liquidation preferences assumption. Probably a lot I'm missing. There should be an easier way for a prospect to simulate a cap table with a simple set of assumptions.
- avn2109 11y agoA good first approximation is to regard your after-tax equity upside == 0 in all ventures that you didn't found.
- mahyarm 11y agoOnce your become a $1B+ startup, your options for liquidity events reduce greatly. Fewer and fewer markets can buy your company. Often when a company has a high valuation, people think it's 'too late' to join the unicorn. If the company isn't profitable on some level yet either, it's even worse.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThis is a severely under-appreciated situation. One has to wonder how many good employees a company misses out on because the traditional style of Silicon Valley capitalism is to be one of the first 20 people in the company or you'll be clawing for scraps like the next 2,000.
- shostack 11y agoIs there an opportunity for any meaningful equity/options when joining a company that size? Or should candidates be focused on salary and other benefits at that size?
- bcherry 11y agoAbsolutely. In fact it's somewhat better. If you join a big company like that, they're not going to be able to give you 1% of mythical future company value, but they CAN give you X shares now with very real value. If you join a 500-2000 person company with a $1B+ valuation and stick it out for four years of hard work and promotions - you can easily be looking at a $500k-$2M payout (above and beyond your high salary). More is possible too. This is why even giants like Facebook and Google can still attract top engineers - they can give you equity that's basically equivalent to cash - and lots of it. Joining a smaller company gives you the chance at a massive payout of $10M+ - but I'd bet your 4-year "expected value" would be much less than joining a bigger company. For one - your options are going to be worth anywhere between $0 and $1B - but heavily weighted towards zero. Two - you have to actually buy your options with cash, which reduces mobility because this is very risky! This often costs $20k or more. So you may leave your options on the table. Very few people would be leaving options on the table at somewhere like Uber today if they quit. You'd find the money and buy your shares. Three - your potential exits are numerous but many of them are the sort of deals that kind of devalue your equity to near worthless (due to LP) and instead buy the team with employment offers and new golden handcuffs - which can be highly variable. An IPO or mega acquisition is a clean transaction for common stock holders.
- btrautsc 11y agoThis is highly situational. I would love if the best of "X" type employee out there were all hunting for 2-5M valuation (or whatever you consider low) startups - but that isn't as common. Many people are risk averse. I think part of this scenario is that companies raising tens or hundreds of millions at billion++ valuations are hiring "scaling talent". Scaling as in hiring many good to great people, but lots of them, some of whom overlap. Multiple product managers, many great engineers, great heads of sales/ HR/ operations. Oftentimes they are focused on becoming huge, scalable, consistently growing revenue generating operations.