5 ms·
If the shared information is only for IDS alert sharing where any irrelevant information to cyber security is removed, then why do they need immunity from priva
by belorn 11y ago
If the shared information is only for IDS alert sharing where any irrelevant information to cyber security is removed, then why do they need immunity from privacy and antitrust laws?
Surely companies in the US can today report to the police if someone gain illegal access to servers, do a DDOS, or sends fishing/malware to them. If the police then involve the FBI with the case while requesting relevant customer information, what laws would the company break from complying?
- skissane 11y agoSurely the company can just go to the FBI/DHS/etc directly if they wish? IANAL, but if a company has information which it reasonably believes to be evidence of a crime, what court would find it illegal for them to volunteer it to the federal government?
- tptacek 11y agoNo, they in the general case cannot.
- skissane 11y agoWhat law would they be breaking? Criminal law? Contract law? Even if it were technically a crime to tell something to the federal government, I can't imagine the government would actually prosecute you for doing it (why would they act against their own interests?) And, if a term of a contract prevents you from providing the government with evidence of a crime, surely that contract term is void as contrary to public policy. And any state or local law which purports to prohibit revealing information to the federal government is surely to that extent unconstitutional.