3 ms·
> Some interfaces may be defined to use macros, and some platforms may make things work when compiled through the C compiler but not through the dynamic-linker
by pcwalton 11y ago
> Some interfaces may be defined to use macros, and some platforms may make things work when compiled through the C compiler but not through the dynamic-linker interface. One example that I've run into recently, when binding things in Rust, is the cmsg API, which is primarily defined in terms of macros to walk a heterogeneous array, and has to be reimplemented in Rust (with platform-specific code):
The worst offender I've seen here is Xlib, which has to recreate the internal layout of large structs like Display that have haphazardly grown fields over the decades in order to deal with macros that reach into them: https://github.com/servo/rust-xlib/blob/master/src/xlib.rs#L1101 https://github.com/servo/rust-xlib/blob/master/src/xlib.rs#L...
- tedunangst 11y agoThere are C binding equivalents for many of the macros in Xlib (having played this game before and recently). This may be slower than a macro, but you can usually cache the result. But really, shouldn't you be using (XML/)XCB? :)
- pcwalton 11y agoLast I looked into it GLX didn't work well with XCB. You can use XCB for some stuff, but you can't drop Xlib. It doesn't look like this has changed, unless this page is out of date: http://xcb.freedesktop.org/opengl/#index5h1 http://xcb.freedesktop.org/opengl/#index5h1
- geofft 11y agoFascinating! I was wondering why nobody had done an XCB-based set of X bindings for Rust, given that XCB was basically designed for this purpose (well-typed, high-level metadata to generate good bindings from). If I'm reading that page correctly, the problem is that GLX is specified as an API + implied ABI, not a wire protocol, and part of that API/ABI contract is "I was compiled with <X11/X11.h> and -lX11, and you'd better give me structures compatible with those"? And half of the GLX implementations are closed-source? Sigh.