4 ms·
Trickery like this has been long used in the automobile industry. VW is just the first to exaggerate it and getting caught. Not a big deal, imho. There are far
by mschuster91 11y ago
Trickery like this has been long used in the automobile industry. VW is just the first to exaggerate it and getting caught.
Not a big deal, imho. There are far bigger threats to the environment than all cars combined - just look at all those freight ships burning bunker fuel, coal power plants emitting more radioactivity than a decades old nuclear plant...
- nsnick 11y agoFreight ships are actually very green when compared to airplanes, cars and trains. You have to look at emissions per kg per mile.
- mschuster91 11y agoThe problem is the fuel itself, as long as you're in international waters you can use as sulphur-rich fuel as you like. Sulphur rich fuel is the cheapest of the lot and because it has no other uses beside international water fuel for freighters, this shit accounts for huge percentages of sulphur emissions. edit: Reason for this is that burning sulphur in fuel produces sulphur dioxide, which when combined with rain or natural humidity, makes acid rain.
- jfoutz 11y agoThe engines are really efficient. Unfortunately, the cheapest fuel has a lot of sulphur in it, so there's a lot of sulphur dioxide that comes out of the engine. Low sulphur fuel is 4x the cost. So, yeah. I don't think the cargo ships are villains or anything, but one of them is worth 50 million cars, for that specific type of emission. (cars would be higher, but they're regulated.). Generally it's turning around, different countries are requiring low sulphur fuel, in spite of the cost. The us was January, i think.
- LeChuck 11y ago>Low sulphur fuel is 4x the cost. It's more like double the cost. Your point stands, though. http://www.bunkerworld.com/prices/port/nl/rtm/ http://www.bunkerworld.com/prices/port/nl/rtm/
- mschuster91 11y ago> Generally it's turning around, different countries are requiring low sulphur fuel, in spite of the cost. That may be true for local waters (iirc 12 nautical miles from the land). International waters, not so much.
- chulk90 11y agoUnfortunately that's incorrect. VW is the only automobile manufacturer which deliberately (and delicately) cheated the diesel emissions test. For example, BMW's diesel engines emit lower emissions than what they specify (which is awesome!).
- jacquesm 11y ago> VW is the only automobile manufacturer which deliberately (and delicately) cheated the diesel emissions test. How can you state that with certainty?
- ceejayoz 11y agoIf not now, I'd expect we can state it with certainty after a few months. Every car model on the market will probably be getting a test similar to the one that caught VW shortly.
- bitsoda 11y agoDon't forget animal agriculture.
- heygrady 11y agohttp://message.snopes.com/showthread.php?t=77718 http://message.snopes.com/showthread.php?t=77718 Cows eat grass, not fossil fuels. Measuring the impact of agriculture vs. transportation should take the source of the pollutants into account.
- mcguire 11y agoOn the other, other hand, many cows are not grass-fed and there's fossil fuels in them thar corn kernels. Second order effects and all...
- heygrady 11y ago... like the gas used for farm equipment? Or the fossil fuels used in some fertilizers? Sure. It's a common talking point to mention "cow farts" and "cow burps" because they emit greenhouse gasses. But generally the greenhouse gasses emitted by cows are from the organic matter that they were fed. Excluding the farm equipment and fossil-fuel-based fertilizer, cow burps form a natural closed loop. Meaning, grow corn or grass and it takes in greenhouse gasses from the soil and the air. Feed it to a cow and it releases those same greenhouse gasses. Cows and plants by themselves are not actually contributing greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere in a manner that contributes to global warming. Meaning, if you're worried about cow burps or humans breathing... stop worrying about it. And if you're pointing out that animals emit greenhouse gasses... cool, but that is irrelevant to a rational discussion of emissions that lead to climate change. For agriculture, the system becomes imbalanced when you add in the emissions of the industrial farm equipment and the shipping infrastructure to getting food from the farm to the the table. But that imbalance is what we're trying to address when we talk about transitioning to more fuel efficient vehicles or more sustainable farming practices (like not using fossil fuels in fertilizer). So, mentioning agriculture as a polluter is typically a red herring. At first blush it seems reasonable because there are a lot of farm animals that emit greenhouse gasses. However, including agriculture in a discussion of emissions is usually disingenuous or misinformed.