Spctl(1) gives you Gatekeeper's acceptance status. If you disabled it, it will (almost) always say "accepted", but in this case it may be "accepted because you

Spctl(1) gives you Gatekeeper's acceptance status. If you disabled it, it will (almost) always say "accepted", but in this case it may be "accepted because you turned me off, you XXX." Check the spctl(1) manpage for more options. A recent version will support the --enforce-assessment option to tell you what the real answer is. And turn the dang thing back on while you're at it. :-)