5 ms·
I got an asthma inhaler from my family doctor for what turned out to be a collapsed lung, many years ago.
by davidw 11y ago
I got an asthma inhaler from my family doctor for what turned out to be a collapsed lung, many years ago.
- erroneousfunk 11y agoA few years ago, I was fresh out of college and working at large university with a very good teaching hospital. I was making $30k/year, but had amazing Cadillac health insurance. I started developing asthma (unbeknownst to me. It was caused by a very gradual onset allergy, and I had never had asthma before), wasn't able to walk up a short flight of stairs on my way to work one day, and, instead of turning right to go to the office, I decided to turn left to go to the urgent care center attached to the school. I wasn't waiting more than 5 minutes (for a walk in!), was seen by two doctors and at least one nurse, including a pulmonary specialist, got a chest x-ray, a breathing test, lots of stethoscope exams, and diagnosed (correctly!) with asthma. I don't remember how long I was seen for, but it was a very long time, for what most doctors would probably consider to be a fairly straightforward diagnosis. (Oh! And it was all free -- they didn't even bother to mail me a statement afterwards. I gave them a $20 bill for the co-pay, $5 for the prescription and that was the end of it) Around the same time, a friend of mine, in a different school, going to a not great school clinic with his school's official insurance plan, was in a similar situation to yours, where a collapsed lung was misdiagnosed as "you're just tired, get more sleep," without an exam. (Granted, as an engineering major, he did need to get more sleep, but still!) As you might imagine, there were some pretty hefty hospital bills later on when his condition deteriorated... Anyway, your situation sounds terrible, and I wouldn't be surprised if the collapsed lung misdiagnosis was fairly common. "Collapsed lung" just seems like one of those things that's really easy to misdiagnose (in some presentations, at least) as a number of other things, unless you're good with a stethoscope, and/or have access to medical imaging equipment (and the will to use it!). Ugh. It's so absurd to me how fantastic and thorough my treatment was at one school (I was on the same insurance plan the students were), and how badly the screwed up a similar situation at a school just 10 miles away -- both with nearly equal tuition rates and health insurance plan costs.
- davidw 11y agoIt all turned out ok, because I could tell there was something wrong, went and got x-rays and eventually got operated on. This was all 20 years ago. Apparently, tall-ish, skinny guys in their early 20ies are one of the highest risk groups for collapsed lungs - the other being older smokers, which sounds more like what you'd expect.
- erroneousfunk 11y agoHa! Yup, my friend with the collapsed lung was very tall, very skinny, and 21 at the time. This college clinic also misdiagnosed a pregnancy as "you stopped menstruating because of your low weight" in a friend of mine who came in, literally saying "I think I'm pregnant." (You'd think that would be the first test a college clinic would do!) In both situations, they figured something was wrong a little while later, and surgery did the trick! Glad it turned out well for you too!
- protomyth 11y agoWonder if that's the genius from IHS (Indian Health Service) that insisted my co-worker had AIDS when he went in for flu symptoms. The doctor had "seen it" and since my co-worker took the normal path to be a drug and alcohol counselor he fit the doctor's criteria. He had to go home and tell his wife. The negative blood test came back a week later. They shuffled said doctor to somewhere else instead of canning the idiot.