5 ms·
They change the sound in transliterating it anyway. Would you prefer bro-tli or bro-ee-tli?
by StavrosK 11y ago
They change the sound in transliterating it anyway. Would you prefer bro-tli or bro-ee-tli?
- nrr 11y agoEr, no, the transliteration of "ö" to "oe" does not change the sound. This is considered a feature of the orthography of German, and you see this kind of thing in, e.g., crossword puzzles.
- StavrosK 11y agoI meant transliteration to English. No English speaker will pronounce the o with the umlaut, so you have to pick how you want English speakers to pronounce your word from the two alternatives above. Bro-li sounds much better to me than bro-ee-li.
- TillE 11y agoEnglish speakers don't pronounce "oe" as a diphthong either.
- _delirium 11y agoSometimes they do, sometimes they don't. It doesn't really have any consistent English pronunciation, since it appears in a bunch of different morphological contexts, and in loanwords from at least five or six different languages. Some examples: phoenix (1 syllable, 'ee'), Zoe (2 syllables, 'oh-ee'), Joe (1 syllable, 'oh'), Joel (either 1 or 2 syllables, depending on schwa insertion), canoe (1 syllable, 'oo'), Dostoevsky (2 syllables, 'oh-eh' or 'oh-yeh'), coed (2 syllables, 'oh-eh'), etc. If I saw something like Broetli and didn't immediately recognize the Germanic origin, I could see myself easily misanalyzing it as Bro-etli and pronouncing it that way.
- anentropic 11y agoExcept... 'oe' at the end of words is rare in English, but when we have it we pronounce it like 'o' eg: hoe sloe (both rhyme with 'bro') to get a 'bro-ee' effect you'd need a 'oey' or some other spelling
- StavrosK 11y agoAre you saying you'd pronounce "broetli" as "brotli"? I think that puts you in a very small minority.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- biafra 11y agoAnd even earlier the ö was transliterated from oe. The e was pulled on top of the o. The e was then changed to two dots. Probably because of laziness. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanic_umlaut#Orthography_and_design_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanic_umlaut#Orthography_an...
- cpeterso 11y agoWhat is the pronunciation of Google's "brotli"?