3 ms·
> The disaster could have been forseen and prevented. As in the Chernobyl case, it was a human, not technology, that was mainly responsible for the disaster. I
by ekianjo 11y ago
> The disaster could have been forseen and prevented. As in the Chernobyl case, it was a human, not technology, that was mainly responsible for the disaster.
It's always easy to say that with hindsight. Remind me, how frequent are Magnitude 9 earthquakes resulting in massive Tsunami?
Of course you can plan for everything, but there's always something that occurs you did not think of. The good thing is, we learn from previous mistakes and plan better accordingly next time.
> Have we learnt anything since then?
Nice punchline to finish your article, nihilist-like, but completely nonsensical. Of course we have learnt a lot since Chernobyl, and designed subsequent plants to be much more safe based on what happened there.
- mixedbit 11y agoDon Norman, the author of "The Design of Everyday Things", writes that in most cases when the fault is attributed to human operator, it is actually a design error.
- richmarr 11y agoIn the case of Chernobyl the accident wasn't attributed to a human operator. The safeguards built into the reactor had been disabled to perform an experiment to test a potential new safety feature.
- pdkl95 11y agoThat "new safety feature" was a foolish attempt to patch the terrible design of the reactor. (see my other post) Everything about that situation was terrible: the badly design reactor, the laughably-bad "safety feature" try wanted to use as a workaround, the untrained operators that were ordered to run the test, and the Soviet politics that caused the foolish rush to complete the test. All of these factors "caused" the disaster. The combination of these failures created a situation that was far more dangerous than a single design problem or human error.
- Swizec 11y ago> Of course we have learnt a lot since Chernobyl, and designed subsequent plants to be much more safe based on what happened there. Unfortunately the anti-nuclear movement won and we are unable to build those safe subsequent plants because of political pressures. Half of nuclear reactors in the US, and likely the world, are over 30 years old.[1] They are licensed for 40 years [2], but can apply for a 20 year extension [2]. The last new reactor came online in 1996, and the next one is likely to come online this year. The Chernobyl disaster happened in 1986, 29 years ago. It will be at least another 10 years, 30 being likelier, before all those things we learned become entirely useful. [1] http://money.cnn.com/2011/03/15/news/economy/nuclear_plants_us/ http://money.cnn.com/2011/03/15/news/economy/nuclear_plants_... [2] http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=228&t=21 http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=228&t=21
- guscost 11y agoIf I had to pick one outlandish conspiracy theory to believe, it would be that the Chernobyl disaster was not an accident. It seems unlikely that someone could accidentally engineer a reactor as ludicrously unsafe as Chernobyl, at the time it was built. And you couldn't plan a better PR move to turn people against nuclear power. Guess which large-ish economy is built on petrochemical exports? But I'm ignoring Hanlon's Razor, of course.
- dfox 11y agoFrom purely technical standpoint, there is essentially nothing that you can learn from Chernobyl that wasn't known in 1986, and all that essentially boils down to "don't do that".
- pdkl95 11y ago> Chernobyl The RBMC design was always known to be an absolutely terrible idea because it's use of graphite as a moderator that required active cooling, creating an inherently unsafe positive void coefficient[1]. In fact, this was such a problem that there was concern before the disaster that the ~60 seconds the emergency diesel pumps would require before they could pump enough coolant would not be fast enough to protect the reactor if the main electric pumps failed. The "test" that was being conducted at the time of the disaster (and was the direct cause of the reactor going prompt-critical) was a shockingly foolish attempt to let the momentum of the electrical turbines (without any input steam) continue to power the pumps and keep the coolant flowing for a few seconds to fill that gap in time while the diesel pumps got up to speed[1]. Chernobyl was never a sane design, and no other power plant design - before or after - has such a blatant disregard for safety. Unfortunately, Soviet politics and the desire to keep their nuclear weapons program secret kept these problems from reaching the people with the power to do anything about it. > designed subsequent plants to be much more safe Absolutely. We had safer designs decades ago (and even better ideas[2] today), but upgrading to these safer designs has been hindered at every step by radiophobic activists and "not in my backyard" politics. So we're stuck with minor revisions (if any) to reactors designs from the 50s-70s. If the general public viewed the computer industry like they perceive the nuclear industry, the average person would know vaguely that the discovery of the transistor was probably very useful, while being concerned that computers took up far too much space and burned out vacuum tubes far to often. [1] http://www.hiroshimasyndrome.com/chernobyl.html http://www.hiroshimasyndrome.com/chernobyl.html [2] http://thoriumremix.com/th/ http://thoriumremix.com/th/
- ekianjo 11y ago> Absolutely. We had safer designs decades ago (and even better ideas[2] today), but upgrading to these safer designs has been hindered at every step by radiophobic activists and "not in my backyard" politics. So we're stuck with minor revisions (if any) to reactors designs from the 50s-70s. There are still countries investing in nuclear energy, like China, and I suppose these new reactors are made to the latest norms of safety. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_China